Evidence from three taxonomically distinct species for a non-AhR mechanism of developmental neurotoxicity of an environmentally derived mixture of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

Abstract

Typical environmental exposures to the toxic class of chemicals known as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) involve complex mixtures; however, relatively few mechanistic toxicity studies have evaluated them as environmental mixtures, instead focusing on individual compounds or simple mixtures. In this study, we first derived Republic Sediment Extract (REPSE), a complex PAH mixture extracted from sediment at the Republic Creosoting site of the Elizabeth River in Norfolk, Virginia. After characterizing the PAH contents of REPSE, we evaluated its mechanisms of developmental neurotoxicity in three evolutionarily distinct taxa, leveraging the unique strengths of Atlantic killifish, zebrafish, and Caenorhabditis elegans as model species, with a focus on the Aryl hydrocarbon Receptor (AhR) pathway. Embryonic REPSE exposure caused induction of CYP1A in both fish species at sub-teratogenic concentrations, consistent with activation of the canonical AhR pathway. These sub-teratogenic exposures nevertheless induced neurotoxicity across both fish species, altering neurobehavioral phenotypes in fish, and induced dopaminergic neuronal damage in worms, again at non-teratogenic concentrations. To determine whether these effects were linked to canonical AhR response pathways, we examined killifish offspring from the pollution-adapted Republic Creosoting population, which exhibited characteristic recalcitrance to CYP1A induction, but remained susceptible to the neurobehavioral effects of REPSE. The induction of neuronal damage in worms provides orthogonal evidence for a non-AhR mechanism, because C. elegans AhR is not transcriptionally activated by PAHs as in vertebrates. Further probing of potential mechanisms underlying REPSE-induced neurotoxicity in worms revealed altered neuronal redox status (roGFP) and energy availability (ATP:ADP ratio). Collectively, our multispecies approach reveals conserved mechanisms of PAH mixture neurotoxicity, including effects that extend beyond canonical AhR signaling.