Time-resolved inference of gene regulatory networks underlying human cranial neural crest development suggests novel risk genes for orofacial clefting.

Abstract

Cranial neural crest cells (CNCCs) play a central role in shaping the human head and face. Aberrant CNCC differentiation contributes to craniofacial birth defects, particularly non-syndromic cleft lip with or without cleft palate (nsCL/P), one of the most common congenital disorders. Although the number of genetic variants associated with this condition is steadily increasing, it remains challenging to determine if and how these variants may contribute to disease development. The majority of these variants lie within non-coding regulatory elements that govern cell-type and stage-specific gene expression, which is orchestrated by dynamic gene regulatory networks (GRNs). Despite extensive work in model organisms, a time-resolved, multi-omics perspective of GRNs controlling CNCC differentiation in a human system is still lacking. To fill this gap, we generated paired transcriptomic and chromatin accessibility data at four timepoints during in vitro differentiation of CNCCs derived from human induced pluripotent stem cells. Integrating these two modalities enabled time-resolved inference of GRNs and identification of dynamic regulatory relationships, including stage-specific roles of core transcription factors. Leveraging these time-resolved GRNs, we mapped 29 nsCL/P associated variants linked to 70 putative target genes, with 40 located outside the associated genomic loci, suggesting novel distal regulatory relationships. Integration of these data with complementary time-course scRNA-seq data revealed an ectomesenchymal-biased subpopulation of CNCCs as particularly sensitive to genetic variants associated with nsCL/P. We provide a time-resolved inference of GRN in human CNCC differentiation, allowing us to determine the dynamics of stage-specific core regulatory programs that are otherwise missed in analyses based on a single time snapshot. To our knowledge, the data represent the first multi-omics map of human CNCC with temporal resolution, which expands the understanding of early human craniofacial development, refines variant-to-gene assignment, prioritizes candidate risk genes and cell states relevant to nsCL/P. Our findings demonstrate the relevance of studying the dynamics upon differentiation rather than just one fixed timepoint and offer a valuable basis for further investigation of non-coding variation in CNCC-related disorders.