Search bioRxiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.64898/2026.05.13.724469

Comparative benchmarking of CRISPRi and CasRx in standardized pluripotent stem cell platforms reveals context-dependent knockdown performance

Ni, L.·Murakami, T.·Suzuki, S.·Hamao, M.·Nakamura, M.·Okubo, C.·Takahashi, K.
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Advances in transcriptome profiling have revealed transcriptomic differences across different cellular states. However, functional interpretation requires precise perturbation tools and experimental frameworks. This study benchmarked two widely used modalities: CRISPR interference (CRISPRi) and Cas13d/CasRx. A standardized workflow was established to generate human pluripotent stem cells (PSCs) with inducible ZIM3-dCas9 or CasRx expression. The cell lines were subjected to flow cytometry, copy number, and immunocytochemical analyses. The knockdown performance was validated via robust OCT4 suppression and the expected downstream effects on pluripotency genes. Time-course measurements indicated that CRISPRi produced faster and stronger repression but slower recovery after inducer withdrawal. In contrast, CasRx yielded slower and typically weaker knockdown with rapid reversibility. Furthermore, a key limitation of CRISPRi was demonstrated using the ATF5-NUP62 locus, wherein CRISPRi could co-repress genes with overlapping promoter regions. In contrast, CasRx avoids these limitations and supports isoform-resolved targeting of circular and alternatively spliced transcripts, albeit with variable efficiency. These results provide practical guidance for selecting complementary knockdown tools to improve the interpretability of transcriptomic function studies. MOTIVATIONAdvances in transcriptome profiling have enabled the detection of subtle cell type-specific differences. However, mechanistic interpretation still depends on perturbation tools that can modulate transcripts with high precision and efficiency. Recent CRISPR-based modalities, CRISPRi and Cas13/CasRx, function as robust and orthogonal methods to achieve the knockdown of specific gene targets. However, a standardized approach for cell line preparation and comparative studies on their relative performances and limitations remains unclear. Consequently, this study presents a standardized workflow for generating cell lines that support high-efficiency knockdown using CRISPRi and CasRx. Moreover, it compares the trade-offs in potency, reversibility, and isoform resolution, along with a practical overview of method-specific pitfalls to guide tool selection and data interpretation in future studies. HIGHLIGHTSO_LIDoxycycline-inducible AAVS1 knock-in human PSC platforms for CRISPRi (ZIM3-dCas9) and CasRx (RfxCas13d) were generated to enable standardized RNA perturbation experiments. C_LIO_LIThe prepared cell lines demonstrated strong OCT4 knockdown, with expected downstream effects on the expression of another pluripotency gene, NANOG. C_LIO_LIA comparison of knockdown characteristics and their reversibility revealed rapid and sustained repression with CRISPRi, whereas slow but rapid recovery was observed with CasRx. C_LIO_LIA CRISPRi-specific off-target effect arising from TSS proximity/overlap (ATF5-NUP62) was identified, whereas CasRx achieved ATF5 knockdown without collateral repression of the neighboring NUP62 gene. C_LIO_LICasRx enables isoform-resolved knockdown of structural isoforms (circHIPK3 vs. linear HIPK3 mRNA) and splice isoforms (RAB6A-iso1 vs. RAB6A-iso2). C_LI

Explore related subjects

cell biologyPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Ni, L., Murakami, T., Suzuki, S., Hamao, M., Nakamura, M., Okubo, C., Takahashi, K.. 2026-05-14. Comparative benchmarking of CRISPRi and CasRx in standardized pluripotent stem cell platforms reveals context-dependent knockdown performance. https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.05.13.724469

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

Not all TOP RNAs are created equal: 3'UTR length and TSS selection predict the translational regulation of LARP1-bound mRNAs in CD4+ T cells

Naive T cells are poised for activation and contain a pool of translationally repressed ribosomal protein (RP) mRNA prepared to induce ribosome biogenesis to support protein synthesis, cell growth and proliferation. RP mRNA are the prototypical members of a class of transcripts initiating at cytosine followed by a CU rich element called terminal oligo pyrimidine (TOP) RNAs. TOP RNAs are regulated by an RNA binding protein LARP1, which promotes transcript stabilisation and translational repression. We investigated LARP1 function in T cell activation by generating cross-linking immunoprecipitation (CLIP) datasets detailing the LARP1-RNA interactions in naive and activated CD4+ T cells and identifying novel TOP RNAs. TOP RNAs identified by this analysis were functionally diverse. RP mRNAs were typified by high stability, and translational repression in naive T cells followed by MTORC1-dependent translation increases following T cell activation. However, other TOP RNAs varied in these aspects of their regulation. Notably, TOP RNAs with longer 3'UTRs had a relaxed dependency on LARP1 for stability and a reduced dependency on MTORC1 for their translation. Transcription start site heterogeneity also impacted TOP RNA regulation by generating a mixture of transcript isoforms with different TOP motif lengths. Longer terminal oligo pyrimidine stretches were associated with a greater dependency on MTORC1 for translation. Differential regulation of TOP RNAs may allow tuneable translational responses to MTORC1 and indicates potential roles for LARP1 beyond translation regulation and stability.

cell biology↗
bioRxiv2026

Sex-specific metabolic regulation by the Drosophila RNA-binding protein Nab2

Conserved RNA binding proteins (RBPs) regulate key steps of gene expression including mRNA processing, export, localization, stability and translation. Human ZC3H14 is a conserved RBP that regulates pre-mRNA processing in neurons and loss of ZC3H14 leads to neurological defects. Studies of Nab2, the Drosophila orthologue of ZC3H14, have identified potential target RNAs involved in metabolism, suggesting Nab2 may influence neurometabolic circuitry. Here, we show a female-specific increase in dilp2 and dilp5 mRNA levels. The dilps encode insulin-like peptides that signal from the brain insulin producing cells (IPCs) to peripheral tissues. Nab2null females have enlarged lipid droplets in the fat body, a tissue analogous to human adipose tissue and liver. Notably, neuronal depletion of Nab2 increases lipid droplet size while neuronal expression of Nab2 in Nab2null female rescues this phenotype supporting a role for Nab2 in a neuronal circuit that regulates dilp levels. Furthermore, depletion of dilp2 or dilp5 from IPCs rescues the enlarged lipid droplet phenotype in Nab2null females indicating that elevated dilp2/dilp5 contributes to enlarged lipid droplets. Together, these data support a female-specific role for Nab2 in brain neurons to support insulin signaling and fat storage, expanding the known functions of RBPs linking neuronal function and metabolic homeostasis.

cell biology↗
bioRxiv2026

Deep generative embeddings of gene expression and splicing reposition the interpretation of single-cell transcriptomic signatures

Single-cell transcriptomic analysis predominantly derives cell identity from gene expression analysis, while alternative splicing is processed separately despite its fundamental role for cell homeostasis. To overcome the limits of separate investigations, we developed a probabilistic deep learning framework, Crecerelle, enabling resolution of the contributions of gene expression and alternative splicing in each cell. Crecerelle learns cell embeddings from gene expressions and alternative splicing isoforms, to decipher their mutually dependent impact on the functional characterisation of cells in a data-driven manner, exemplified for the Tabula Muris dataset. This is enabled through a zero-and-N-inflated Dirichlet-Multinomial for a variational autoencoder that learns cell embeddings solely from splicing profiles, as well as a bi-modal variational autoencoder with a relevance-weighted mixture-of-experts variational posterior to consolidate the modality-specific contribution at single-cell level. Crecerelle reveals cell-type-specific isoform markers as well as subpopulations with unique isoforms and uncovers regulatory and disease-associated pathways not detected by gene expression analyses alone. This scalable and interpretable framework thus allows a more holistic study of transcriptomic regulation and will open a route to modality-relevance-weighted investigations across single-cell multiomics datasets and their influence on cellular homeostasis, tissue development and disease phenotypes.

cell biology↗