Search bioRxiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.64898/2026.04.02.716222

Omitted familial extrinsic risk inflates inferred intrinsic lifespan heritability

Kornilov, S. A.
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Shenhar et al. (2026) report 50% "intrinsic" lifespan heritability after calibrating a one-component correlated-frailty survival model to Scandinavian twin lifespans. Their framework is mathematically coherent, but the intrinsic component is not identified if heritable, mortality-relevant extrinsic susceptibility is omitted at calibration. We show that one-component calibration absorbs omitted familial extrinsic structure into the intrinsic frailty scale parameter{sigma}{theta} , and that this variance absorption is visible through separate diagnostics (1) Variance absorption. Under misspecification,{sigma}{theta} is inflated by +22.1% (95% CI: 21.5-22.7%), corresponding to +49% inflation in [Formula]. Falconer h2 is downstream of calibration and inherits a +9.2 pp bias (95% CI: 8.7-9.7). The{sigma}{theta} inflation is model-general: +22% (GM), +18% (MGG), +14% (SR); any dependence summary that is strictly increasing in{sigma}{theta} inherits this inflation, so Falconer h2 is one affected downstream quantity among many (Corollary B3). (2) Structural fingerprint. In the joint twin survival surface S(t1, t2), misspecification produces systematic dependence errors (ISE 48x that of the recovery model). Conditional twin dependence is inflated at all ages, peaking at age 80 ({Delta}r = 0.048). (3) Specificity. The bias requires an omitted component that is both heritable and mortality-relevant. Three negative controls, a boundary check ({rho} = 0), and a two-component recovery refit ({sigma}{theta} restored to within -3.2%) establish specificity. ACE decomposition yields C {approx} 0 throughout: the omitted extrinsic component loads onto A (because it is shared 1.0/0.5 in MZ/DZ), so switching summary statistics does not restore identification. (4) Sensitivity and falsifiability. Over an empirically anchored regime ({sigma}{gamma} [isin] [0.30, 0.65],{rho} [isin] [0.20, 0.50]), Falconer bias ranges from +2.8 to +18.9 pp (mean 9 pp). If{rho} is sufficiently negative, the bias reverses sign in all three model families (Corollary B4). A full-likelihood robustness check shows that this upward pull is partly structural and partly estimator-specific: in the same misspecified one-component model, ML still inflates{sigma}{theta} (+3%), whereas matching only rMZ inflates it much more (+21%). These results do not resolve true intrinsic heritability but establish that Shenhars 50% estimate carries a structured, model-general upward bias originating in the fitted latent variance{sigma}{theta} .

Explore related subjects

geneticsPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Kornilov, S. A.. 2026-04-06. Omitted familial extrinsic risk inflates inferred intrinsic lifespan heritability. https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.04.02.716222

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

Generation of a transgenic cephalopod

Coleoid cephalopods (cuttlefish, octopus, and squid) are marine mollusks with elaborate nervous systems that support a diverse repertoire of complex behaviors. These include the neural control of the color, pattern, and texture of the skin, facilitating both adaptive camouflage and innate patterning that may reflect internal state. The development of transgenic cephalopods expressing fluorescent proteins, optogenetic actuators, and reporters of neural activity would contribute a new and important technology to cephalopod biology. The generation of transgenic cephalopods, however, has remained a major challenge. Here, we report the development of stable transgenic dwarf cuttlefish (Ascarosepion bandense) expressing ubiquitous nuclear-localized mScarlet, a red fluorescent protein. We evaluated multiple strategies for transgenesis, and established cuttlefish lines using both CRISPR and the transposons Sleeping Beauty and Minos. The stable expression of transgenes enabled live imaging of cell dynamics during embryonic development. The Minos transposon emerged as the most efficient transgenesis strategy and is adaptable to promoters and transgenes of choice. These strategies now enable the generation of diverse genetic tools for mechanistic studies of cephalopod biology.

genetics↗
bioRxiv2026

Large language model-based bibliometric evaluation of population descriptors in human genetics

As the use of population descriptors such as race, ethnicity, and ancestry have become increasingly common in modern genetics research, there have been growing calls to critically examine their use. Most notably, in 2023, the National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) published a report titled Using Population Descriptors in Genetics and Genomics Research: A New Framework for an Evolving Field, which included eight specific and actionable recommendations for researchers to implement the ethical and accurate use of population descriptors in genetic research. Here, we use the 2023 NASEM report as a benchmark to analyze the use of population descriptors in genome-wide association studies (GWAS). We develop a general toolkit for large language model-based bibliometrics, operationalize the report's recommendations into an evaluation framework, and apply this framework to evaluate all 4,007 papers from the GWAS Catalog published between 2007 and 2025 with full text available on PubMedCentral. We find significant improvements in adherence to NASEM report recommendations over time. However, most improvements predate the publication of the NASEM report itself, suggesting the report functioned primarily as a synthesis of existing best practices rather than a catalyst for change. We conclude by highlighting opportunities for growth in the field of human genetics.

genetics↗
bioRxiv2026

Mitigating biases of rescaling in forward-in-time population genetic simulations

Forward-in-time population genetic simulations are widely used in evolutionary analyses, but simulating large populations and long genomic regions remains computationally demanding. To reduce this cost, parameter rescaling is widely employed, in which the original evolutionary process is approximated by one with a smaller population size and fewer generations. Recently, several studies using the SLiM simulator have raised concerns about the accuracy of this rescaling approach. In this study, we show that many of the biases reported in these studies can be mitigated by using a different simulation algorithm. These results reveal that the accuracy of parameter rescaling depends on how well the simulation algorithm preserves diffusion-limit properties under rescaling.

genetics↗