Why Are CD8 T Cell Epitopes of Human Influenza A Virus Conserved?

Abstract

The high-degree conservation of CD8 T cell epitopes of influenza A virus (IAV) may allow T cell-inducing vaccines effective across different strains and subtypes. This conservation is not fully explained by functional constraint, since additional mutation(s) can compensate the replicative fitness loss of IAV escape-variant. Here, we propose three additional mechanisms that contribute to the conservation of CD8 T cell epitopes of IAV. First, influenza-specific CD8 T cells may protect predominantly against severe pathology rather than infection and may only have a modest effect on transmission. Second, polymorphism of human MHC-I gene restricts the advantage of an escape-variant to only a small fraction of human population, who carry the relevant MHC-I alleles. Finally, infection with CD8 T cell-escapevariants may result in compensatory increase in the responses to other epitopes of IAV. A combination of population genetics and epidemiological models is used to examine how the interplay between these mechanisms affects the rate of invasion of IAV escape-variants. We conclude that the invasion of an escape-variant will be very slow with a timescale of decades or longer, even if the escape-variant does not have a replicative fitness loss. Our results suggest T cell-inducing vaccines may not engender the rapid evolution of IAV and serve as a foundation for future modeling works on the long-term effectiveness and impacts of T cell-inducing influenza vaccines. (Word count: 221)\n\nImportanceUniversal influenza vaccines against the conserved epitopes of influenza A virus have been proposed to minimize the burden of seasonal outbreaks and prepare for the pandemics. However, it is not clear to which extent the T cell-inducing vaccines will select for viruses that escape the T cell responses. Our mathematical models suggest how the nature of CD8 T cell protection contributes to the conservation of the CD8 T cell epitopes of influenza A virus. Also, it points out the essential biological parameters and questions that need addressing by future experimental works. (Word count: 91)