Assessing the Potential of Switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) for Storing Carbon Belowground: Insights from a Multi-Site US Study

Abstract

Agricultural intensification depletes belowground carbon (C) stocks, partly due to the exclusion of deep-rooted perennial species from landscapes where they were once dominant. Reintroducing deep-rooted perennials to cultivated land may help to mitigate SOC loss and restore ecosystem function. We quantified the effect of replacing shallow-rooted annual crops with a deep-rooted perennial grass, switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.), by comparing 10 to 30 year-old switchgrass stands with paired annual row crop fields across the central and eastern USA. We hypothesized that switchgrass would store more root C and SOC than neighboring shallow-rooted annual crops, and that these effects would extend deeper than 30 cm. We also evaluated whether switchgrass stimulates decomposition of SOC at depth using radiocarbon (14C) to quantify replacement of slow cycling isotopically depleted SOC. Finally, we explored whether the effect of switchgrass on SOC is moderated by soil chemical and physical properties. While the effect of switchgrass on SOC in the surface 100 cm was positive at most sites, the average effect was highly uncertain and statistically indistinguishable from zero (mean difference in SOC = 0.6 kg C m-2 [95% CI -0.8 to +1.9 kg C m-2]). By contrast, we found that root biomass C was consistently more deeply distributed and more abundant under switchgrass, yielding an estimated additional 0.6 kg C m-2 in the surface 100 cm of soil under switchgrass [95% CI +0.5 to +0.7 kg C m-2]. 14C measurements suggested that root C inputs were adding to existing SOC without stimulating decomposition. The effect of switchgrass on belowground C was not strongly related to any of the environmental factors that we evaluated. Our observations show that root biomass C can contribute substantially to belowground C stocks when deep-rooted perennial grasses replace shallow-rooted annual crops.