Structural covariation between cerebellum and cerebral cortex is atypically modulated by thalamus in autism spectrum disorder

Abstract

Despite its strong interconnectivity with the cerebral cortex, the influence of the human cerebellum on neocortical structure and its role in the development of neuropsychiatric disorders is unclear. Because cerebellar damage in early postnatal life creates a high risk for autism spectrum disorder (ASD), we investigated inter-relationships in cerebello-cerebral morphology. Leveraging a large structural brain MRI dataset in neurotypical children (n=375) and those diagnosed with ASD (n=373), we examined whether volumetric variation in cerebellar structure across individuals was correlated with neocortical variation during development, modeling the thalamus as a moderating coupling factor. We found negative covariation between cerebellar cortical regions and thalamic/sensorimotor neocortical regions, and positive covariation between thalamic and sensorimotor neocortical regions. This pattern aligned with the major disynaptic path of cerebellar inhibition to thalamocortical excitation. Examining the dependence of this structural covariation on ASD diagnosis, we found that neurotypical and ASD children displayed inverted hemispheric biases. In ASD, the thalamus moderated structural associations between the left cerebellum and right sensorimotor cortex. For neurotypical children, right cerebellum and left sensorimotor cortex were coupled. Notably, structural coupling between cerebellum, thalamus, and neocortex was strongest in younger childhood and waned by early adolescence, a time during which behavioral differences were smallest between typically developing and autistic children. In addition to the sensorimotor cortex, cerebellar dentate nuclei in ASD displayed greater coupling to broad neocortical regions, and these nuclei related to cognitive function differently such that greater dentate nuclear volume was associated with greater behavioral impairment in ASD but not in controls. Graph analyses demonstrated that the cerebello-thalamocortical network was more densely and less prolifically interconnected in ASD than in typical development. Taken as a whole, our study reveals a developmental interplay between the cerebellum, thalamus, and neocortex which differs in ASD from neurotypical children. This pattern is consistent with a model of ASD in which early developmental influences of cerebellar output on brain maturation are specifically moderated by cerebello-thalamocortical pathways.