Bruin, W. | Search bioRxiv

bioRxiv2025

Inhibitory control and error processing in Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: A mega-analysis of task-based fMRI data by the ENIGMA-OCD consortium

ObjectiveObsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is a chronic condition in which impaired inhibitory control and excessive error monitoring may contribute to the maintenance of obsessions and compulsions. This mega-analysis investigates neural activation during response inhibition and error processing using adult and pediatric data from the ENIGMA-OCD consortium and the ABCD study. MethodsIndividual participant data was uniformly processed using HALFpipe to extract statistical maps for response inhibition and error processing contrasts. Bayesian multilevel models were used to assess regional and whole-brain effects of OCD, with additional analyses examining the association between the OCD clinical profile and task-related activation. ResultsAcross inhibitory control tasks, both individuals with OCD and control participants showed robust activation in regions implicated in response inhibition and error processing. During response inhibition, compared to controls, adults with OCD showed stronger somatomotor cortex activation, while children with OCD showed stronger occipital cortex activation. Children with likely OCD from the ABCD cohort showed reduced activity in the frontoparietal network in the anterior insula/frontal operculum region. During error processing, relative to controls, adults with OCD showed weaker activation in fronto-striatal regions, while children with OCD showed stronger activation in frontoparietal and attention networks. Greater OCD symptom severity was associated with weaker task-related activation in adults and stronger activation in children during response inhibition. ConclusionCase-control differences in brain activation during inhibitory control varied by age group and task contrast. Symptom severity emerged as the main clinical correlate of activation during inhibition, suggesting that inhibitory control deficits in OCD may be both state-dependent and developmentally specific.

neuroscience↗

bioRxiv2021

Neural excitation/inhibition imbalance and the treatment of severe depression

An influential hypothesis holds that depression is related to a neural excitation/inhibition imbalance, but its role in the treatment of depression remains unclear. Here, we show that unmedicated patients with severe depression demonstrated reduced inhibition of brain-wide resting-state networks relative to healthy controls. Patients using antidepressants showed inhibition that was higher than unmedicated patients and comparable to controls, but they still suffered from severe depression. Subsequent treatment with electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) reduced depressive symptoms, but its effectiveness did not depend on changes in network inhibition. Concomitant pharmacotherapy increased the effectiveness of ECT, but only when the strength of neural inhibition before ECT was within the normal range and not when inhibition was excessive. These findings suggest that reversing the excitation/inhibition imbalance may not be sufficient nor necessary for the effective treatment of severe depression, and that brain-state informed pharmacotherapy management may enhance the effectiveness of ECT.

neuroscience↗