Search bioRxiv⌕ Search

bioRxiv · 10.64898/2026.10.29.762632

How many mutations does it take to evolve a new function?

Abstract

Biochemical and genetic networks in cells evolve to produce new functions. Evolution is guided by the genotype to phenotype map which describes how mutations at the molecular scale lead to changes in network function at the cellular scale. The number of genotypes is astronomically large which makes these maps very high dimensional. In this context, the simple question: How many mutations does it take to evolve a new function?, is usually hard to answer. Here we consider this question in the context of a simple Boolean-network model of a genotype-phenotype map. The nodes and edges of the Boolean network represent the genotype while the Boolean function the network computes is the phenotype. The network evolves by rewiring of its edges, while keeping the number of nodes fixed. We compute the number of mutations needed to achieve a new Boolean function as a function of the number of nodes in the network. We show that the number of mutations scales with the number of nodes of the network as a power-law with an exponent determined by local geometrical features of the genotype-phenotype map. Our theoretical study emphasizes the role of the genotype-phenotype map in determining the time to evolve a new function.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Farheen, N., Boroda, Z., Levien, E., Kondev, J.. 2026-10-30. How many mutations does it take to evolve a new function?. https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.10.29.762632

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

Experimental evolution unveils a role for structural variants and sex-specificity in the genetic architecture of lifespan

Insights into the genetic basis of lifespan evolution can link evolutionary theory with an understanding of health, disease and adaptation. We leverage the power of >200 generations of experimental evolution in a seed beetle to unveil the genomic architecture of lifespan evolution. Replicated populations evolved under regimes favoring either a short or long life, resulting in a near doubling of lifespan. Whole genome re-sequencing revealed that short- and long-lived lines were strongly differentiated (global FST = 0.41) and more than 700 genes showed consistent signs of divergent selection. Remarkably, short- and long-lived lines were consistently divergent in a large number of regions harboring copy-number variants (CNVs), involving >600 genes. The evolution of a long life involved many distinct biological processes, such as DNA fidelity, mitotic integrity, reproduction, metabolism, immunity and stress response. A pedigree-based genome scan for quantitative trait loci (QTLs) uncovered several QTLs with large effects on lifespan, but the genetic basis of a long life was dominated by a very large number of regions with medium and small effects. The genome-wide spatial association with QTL effects was, if anything, stronger for CNVs than for sequence variants. The genetic effects of QTLs on lifespan were positively correlated overall between the sexes, but four regions showed pronounced sex-differences. Our results show that structural variants play a significant role in the evolution of an extended lifespan and the highly polygenic genomic architecture is to some extent sex-specific, consistent with differences in physiology and life history tradeoffs between the sexes.

evolutionary biology↗

Genome-wide fluctuating selection under demographic cycling in Icelandic rock ptarmigan

Understanding how natural populations adapt to continuously shifting environments is central to evolutionary biology. Multi-annual population cycles impose temporally varying selective pressures, yet disentangling the resulting genomic signals from those of sustained directional selection and genetic drift has been challenging due to a lack of high-resolution temporal data. Here we investigate the genomic consequences of demographic cycling in a population of rock ptarmigan (Lagopus muta) from northeastern Iceland. We analyzed whole-genome sequences from 91 individuals sampled over an 11-year period, encompassing two population peaks (2010 and 2018) and two troughs (2007 and 2013). Testing allele frequency change at each SNP against a null model of drift and sampling, we identified candidate loci and grouped them by correlation of their temporal trajectories. Cluster trajectories fluctuated through time, and two were closely correlated with the regional census, one significantly tracking the demographic cycle, while a smaller set changed monotonically in a manner consistent with sustained directional selection. Each cluster contained loci distributed across many chromosomes, indicative of genome-wide responses to selection. The most strongly fluctuating loci overlapped candidate genes of possible functional relevance, most notably CTNNA2 (Catenin Alpha-2), which is associated with startle response and anxiety-like behaviors and may relate to predator avoidance. Our findings indicate that fluctuating selection comprises much of the temporal genomic response in this natural population, and suggest that multi-annual demographic cycles can drive rapid and widespread allele frequency change, highlighting the value of temporal genomics for clarifying the interplay between demography and natural selection in wild populations.

evolutionary biology↗

A single freshwater invasion gave rise to the world's dominant freshwater fish group

The ultraspeciose clade Otophysa - catfishes, carps, minnows, tetras, and their kin - accounts for most vertebrate diversity in modern freshwater ecosystems. However, a controversial assemblage of largely-fragmentary marine fossils has led some authors, most recently Liu et al., to advocate parallel freshwater invasions for this otherwise inland lineage. Here, we test this hypothesis under multiple sources of uncertainty. We provide the first phylogenetic analysis of the recently-named marine fossil genus Sooinichthys, resolving it as sister to all modern otophysans. We also find that Santanichthys, long treated as an early marine otophysan, lacks a Weberian apparatus and plausibly belongs outside Ostariophysi entirely. When increasing the taxon and marker sampling of Liu et al.'s genomic dataset, standardizing their ecological coding, accounting for alternative interpretations of important morphological characters, and applying a suite of biogeographic models, we find a marine origin in only 6 of 132 analyses, and only when enforcing fossil placements inconsistent with our own phylogenetic results. We contend that the parallel freshwater invasion hypothesis of otophysan diversification is an artifact of sparse taxon sampling, taphonomic biases, model selection errors, and fossil overinterpretation. The result is a cautionary case for inferences about the cradle of any ancient freshwater clade.

evolutionary biology↗