Multidimensional Electroglottographic Characterization of Immediate Responses to Straw Phonation: A Pilot Methodological Study in Singers

Abstract

Semi-occluded vocal tract (SOVT) exercises are widely used in voice training and therapy, but their immediate electroglottographic (EGG) effects remain incompletely characterized. In this pilot methodological study, six female community singers completed a no-straw baseline recording and then 1-min straw-phonation exercises with four straws (Household metal, Metal VoiceStraw, plastic, and paper), each followed by a no-straw EGG recording. Thirty 1s recordings were analyzed with a standardized pipeline including contact quotient (CQ), waveform skewness, contact-phase rise/fall timing, temporal skewness (s_t), a normalized derivative asymmetry index (NDAI), average-cycle morphology, and EGG spectral descriptors. Relative to baseline, group-mean CQ was higher after all four straws (by 0.027-0.058), waveform skewness and NDAI were lower, and the EGG spectral centroid was lower (by 9.6-15.3%). Contact-phase timing asymmetry did not change consistently: s_t exceeded baseline after three straws and fell below it after one, and the rise/fall ratio decreased in three to five of six participants depending on the straw. Four participants ranked the Metal VoiceStraw first and two ranked paper first. Because every straw condition followed the baseline, warm-up and order effects cannot be separated from straw effects. These hypothesis-generating results identify CQ, waveform skewness, and EGG spectral centroid as candidate endpoints for a larger controlled study