A putative cis-regulatory element near Shox2 in the jerboa genome (Jaculus jaculus) is not sufficient to alter mouse limb bone lengths

Abstract

Vertebrate limb bones grow at different rates within and between species to achieve a striking variety of proportions and functions. However, most coding mutations that alter bone growth in mice and humans affect the entire skeleton, pointing to cis-regulatory modularity as the primary mechanism to diversify proportion. In a search for causative loci, we previously identified 1,755 disproportionately differentially expressed genes associated with the extreme hindlimb elongation in bipedal jerboas, Jaculus jaculus, compared to laboratory mice. We then took a focused approach to identify putative cis-regulatory elements near select candidate genes in a highly fragmented draft Jaculus jaculus genome assembly. We identified an ATAC-seq peak near Shox2 that was reproducible in jerboa metatarsals and not in radius/ulna. Shox2 gained a novel expression domain in jerboa metatarsals and is both necessary and sufficient to modulate mouse limb bone length. This 139 bp putative enhancer in the jerboa genome centers on a ~1 kb deletion of sequence found broadly throughout placental mammals. Here, we show that replicating the deletion and replacement with the 139 bp jerboa sequence in mice causes no detected phenotype. A genome-wide analysis of our ATAC-seq data using a high-quality Jaculus jaculus genome assembly replicated the peak called at this location but also identified 7,445 peaks that are similarly reproducible in metatarsals and not in radius/ulna. Certainly not all of these peaks are causative, but it is likely that many small-effect mutations diversified proportion. It is therefore crucial to apply unbiased filters to genome-wide analyses and to not assume that the few historically favored genes will have the largest effect.