Not a single clock: multiple behavioral rhythms in perceptual averaging

Abstract

Several theories propose that perception and attention are governed by rhythmic processes that give rise to periodic fluctuations in behavior. However, empirical support for behavioral rhythms has been derived largely from paradigms involving brief, static stimuli. Here, we introduce a temporal averaging task requiring integration of rapidly unfolding visual features. Across three experiments, we tested averaging of orientation, size, and color under different eccentricity conditions. We used a temporally weighted averaging model to assess whether the influence of individual stimulus samples on perceptual estimates exhibits periodic modulation over time. We found no common rhythmic signature across tasks. Instead, orientation and size judgments showed reliable low-frequency modulations (<2.5 Hz), whereas color judgments showed only weak trends. Higher-frequency components (~3.5-8 Hz), often linked to theta and alpha rhythms, were observed only in a subset of participants and were limited to parafoveal orientation processing. These findings challenge the notion of universal behavioral rhythms and instead suggest that temporal dynamics are task-dependent, with slow oscillatory processes emerging as the most consistent feature.