EcoEnamel: Development of a Gelatin-Pectin Film for S. mutans Inhibition and Enamel Preservation in an In Vitro Model

Abstract

Rinsing-dependent dental hygiene presents a significant public health challenge in water-scarce environments. This study investigated combinations of xylitol (Xyl), chitosan (Chi), glycyrrhizin (Gly), epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), dicalcium phosphate (DCP), and nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA) on the primary bacteria behind dental caries, S. mutans. These combinations were assessed for markers of dental caries by biofilm reduction, bacterial killing, and acid buffering against S. mutans when applied to an in vitro simulated enamel model using glass bead surfaces for biofilm formation, and gene expression was subsequently examined via RT-qPCR. Separately, mineral retention was also quantified. The EGCG-DCP-Xyl film demonstrated the highest overall efficacy, achieving a significant reduction in biofilm concentration compared to the untreated control and performing similarly in magnitude to the positive toothpaste control. Dead fluorescence staining confirmed that the EGCG-DCP-Xyl film induced the highest rate of non-viable cells, followed by the Chi-Gly film and the Gly-Xyl film. During 10-day pH cycling, the EGCG-DCP-Xyl and DCP-Xyl formulations buffered pH the most, consistently maintaining mean pH levels safely above the demineralization threshold of pH 5.5. The EGCG-DCP-Xyl also optimized mineral stability with the highest retained calcium concentration, significantly outperforming the Chi-Xyl film. At the transcript level, the EGCG-DCP-Xyl film induced substantial downregulation of key virulence genes, yielding decreases in expression for glucosyltransferase B (gtfB), associated with biofilm synthesis, collagen-binding protein (cnm), associated with tissue invasion, and lactate dehydrogenase (ldh), associated with lactic acid production, compared to the untreated control, with effects comparable in magnitude to the positive toothpaste control. This research suggests that targeting bacterial pathways and mineral loss through a portable film may have potential for preventing dental caries, especially in environments where water is limited. However, additional studies are necessary to evaluate real-world effectiveness.