Open-source benchmarking of dairy and dairy-free products

Abstract

Dairy-free foods must reproduce diverse functions of dairy, from foam stabilization in a latte to acid-gel structure in yogurt and melt-stretch behavior in mozzarella. Public consumer benchmarks rarely compare these categories under a common protocol. Here we analyze data from the NECTAR Taste of the Industry 2026 study, a blinded, randomized, in-person evaluation of commercial dairy-free products and dairy benchmarks. The full study included 2,183 consumers and 112 products across ten categories, with 3,220 product evaluations and 79,027 recorded survey responses, including 35,762 product-linked responses. The ten categories included barista milk, butter, cheddar, cream cheese, creamer, ice cream, fluid milk, mozzarella, sour cream, and Greek style yogurt. Within each category, we compare a dairy benchmark with the dairy-free product selected post hoc as the category leader. Participants rated overall liking, flavor, texture and mouthfeel, appearance, similarity to dairy, and purchase intent on seven-point scales and completed check-all-that-apply questions. In exploratory category-specific equivalence tests using a chosen margin of {+/-}0.05 points, barista milk, creamer, and fluid milk meet this margin. Mozzarella has the largest paired deficit of -1.46 points (unadjusted, p < 0.001), followed by Greek style yogurt and butter; all three remain significant after Holm correction across the ten primary comparisons. Descriptive penalty analysis associates off-flavor, artificial or chemical notes, stale or cardboard notes, bitter taste, and lingering aftertaste with the largest reductions in liking. Together, these results establish the first open sensory benchmark for dairy and dairy-free products, demonstrate that sensory parity is already achievable in several beverage categories, and identify the product categories and sensory attributes that offer the greatest opportunities for future innovation.