Response diversity can stabilize or destabilize community dynamics depending on the number of insensitive species

Abstract

Investigating the factors that stabilize biological communities is a central topic in ecology. Response diversity, defined as variation in species responses to environmental change, has been proposed as a key mechanism underlying the biodiversity-ecosystem functional stability (BEFS) relationship, whereby greater species diversity enhances ecological stability. Previous studies have shown that response diversity promotes ecological stability by generating asynchronous population fluctuations and the resulting compensatory dynamics. Although several metrics have been proposed to quantify response diversity, they do not explicitly consider the presence of insensitive species whose performance is unaffected by current environmental conditions. To examine how insensitive species influence response diversity, species persistence, and ecological stability, we conducted numerical simulations of a generalized Lotka-Volterra model under environmental forcing. We first confirmed that increasing variation among sensitive species increased the response diversity index and stabilized community dynamics. We then examined a scenario in which response diversity depended solely on the proportion of sensitive and insensitive species, assuming that all sensitive species responded identically to environmental change. Under this assumption, the response diversity index was maximized when sensitive and insensitive species occurred in equal proportions, whereas increasing the number of sensitive species monotonically destabilized community dynamics. Consequently, the relationship between response diversity and community stability depended on how response diversity was generated, such that higher response diversity could even be associated with lower community stability. These findings demonstrate that overlooking environmentally insensitive species can obscure the mechanisms linking response diversity and ecological stability. More broadly, our results reveal that response diversity comprises at least two distinct biological components--species sensitivity and response variation among sensitive species--that can have contrasting consequences for community stability. We therefore highlight the need to quantify sensitive species empirically and to develop response diversity metrics that distinguish these components. Author SummaryUnderstanding why some communities remain stable despite environmental change is a longstanding goal in ecology. Response diversity, which refers to differences in how species respond to environmental change, has been proposed as a key mechanism explaining why greater biodiversity (species richness) can promote ecological stability. Because species respond differently to changing environments, declines in some species can be compensated by increases in others, helping to stabilize community dynamics. However, previous studies have rarely considered species that are insensitive to current environmental changes. Using a mathematical model, we show that response diversity can arise from two distinct biological components--the number of sensitive species and variation in their responses--and that these components can have contrasting effects on ecological stability. When response diversity reflects variation among sensitive species, greater response diversity stabilizes community dynamics, as expected. In contrast, when response diversity changes only because of the proportions of sensitive and insensitive species, higher response diversity can be associated with lower community stability. Our findings highlight the importance of quantifying the number of sensitive species and developing response diversity metrics that distinguish species sensitivity from variation in responses among sensitive species.