Comparing Harmonization Approaches for Protocol-Related Variability in Multisite Diffusion MRI Data

Abstract

Diffusion MRI (dMRI) enables assessment of white matter microstructural abnormalities in Alzheimers disease (AD), and multisite datasets enable more robust modeling of non-biological variation that can confound analyses. The Alzheimers Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) includes over 10 dMRI protocols, necessitating robust methods to model protocol-related variability when pooling data. Here, we compared three harmonization approaches: (1) mixed-effects models, (2) ComBat-GAM, and (3) eHarmonize, a reference-based lifespan method. We assessed their ability to reduce protocol-related variability in diffusion tensor imaging fractional anisotropy (FA) and mean diffusivity (MD) while preserving associations with cognitive impairment (CI), and amyloid-beta (A{beta}) and tau PET burden in 1,086 ADNI3/4 participants. All approaches yielded more closely aligned FA/MD distributions across protocols. Associations with clinical indicators of CI were highly consistent across approaches, whereas PET associations were less widespread and more variable. Overall, multiple strategies effectively modeled protocol-related variability while preserving AD-related associations.