Dynamic size-weight changes after object lifting reduce the size-weight illusion

Abstract

In the size-weight illusion, the smaller object from two equally weighted objects is typically perceived as being heavier. One explanation is that the mismatch between the weight expectation based on object size and actual sensory feedback influences heaviness perception. In most studies, the size of an object is perceived before its weight. We investigated whether size changes would influence weight perception if both would be perceived simultaneously. We used virtual reality to change the size and weight of an object after lifting and asked participants to judge whether objects became lighter or heavier. We found that simultaneous size-weight changes greatly reduced the size-weight illusion to perceptual biases below discrimination thresholds. In a control experiment in which we used a standard size-weight illusion protocol with sequential lifts of small and large objects in the same virtual reality setup, we found a larger, typical perceptual bias. These results show that the size-weight illusion is smaller when size and weight information is perceived simultaneously. This provides support for the prediction mismatch theory explaining the size-weight illusion. Furthermore, these findings suggest that the lifting phase is a critical time window during which brain mechanisms comparing perceived and expected weight mediate the size-weight illusion.