Close-Range Interactions Favor Growth in Random-Paired Extracted Soil Bacteria

Abstract

Species interactions at the cellular level are thought to govern the formation and functioning of microbial communities, but direct measurements of species interactions are difficult to perform between the hundreds of different species that constitute most microbial ecosystems. We developed a methodology to examine interactive growth of random cell pairs encapsulated inside 40-70 {micro}m diameter agarose beads. We focused on a sandy soil as a test microbial ecosystem. By using gentle washing procedures, we detached microbial cells from sand and encapsulated them either in the absence or presence of pure culture inoculants. We then tested whether inoculants had on average positive or negative effects on the growth of resident community members depending on the growth substrate. Surprisingly, all the tested inoculants (including Pseudomonas veronii 1YdBTEX2, Pseudomonas putida F1, Pseudomonas protegens CHA0 and Escherichia coli MG1655) stimulated the growth of 40-80 percent of sand-derived cells when grown pair-wise in close proximity (i.e., within the same bead). This was true essentially irrespective of the growth substrate. Beneficial inoculant-sand cell partnerships resulted in up to 100-fold increase in productivity of the sand cell partner and up to 100-fold decrease in that of the inoculant. However, the maximum productivity attained by inoculant-sand cell partners within beads did not surpass that of inoculants alone. Further surprisingly, random pairs of sand cells encapsulated within the same bead also benefited growth in comparison to individual sand cells in a mutualistic manner (i.e., productivity when grown together was greater than the sum of individual productivities), but less than productivities observed in partnerships with the tested inoculants. This suggests that partnerships between inoculants and sand cells are not so much characterized by competition for substrate as by carbon loss through metabolite provision of the inoculant to sand cells (competitive exploitation).