Search bioRxiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/624916

Reassessing the Evidence for Universal School-age Bacillus Calmette Guerin (BCG) Vaccination in England and Wales

Abbott, S.·Christensen, H.·Brooks-Pollock, E.
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

BackgroundIn 2005, England and Wales switched from universal BCG vaccination against tuberculosis (TB) disease for school-age children to targeted vaccination of neonates. We assessed the quantitative evidence that informed this policy change.\n\nMethodsWe recreated a previous approach for estimating the impact of ending the BCG schools scheme in England and Wales, updating the model with parameter uncertainty. We investigated scenarios considered by the UKs Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation, and explored new approaches using notification data. We estimated the number of vaccines needed to prevent a single notification, and the average annual additional notifications caused by ending the BCG schools scheme.\n\nResultsWe found a 1.9% annual decrease in TB incidence rates best matched notification data. We estimate that 1600 (2.5-97.5% Quantiles (Q): 1300 - 2100) vaccines would have been required to prevent a single notification in 2004. If the scheme had ended in 2001, 302 (2.5-97.5% Q: 238 - 369) additional annual notifications would have occurred compared to if the scheme had continued. If the scheme ended in 2016, 120 (2.5-97.5% Q: 88 - 155) additional annual notifications would have occurred.\n\nConclusionsOur estimates of the impact of ending the BCG schools scheme were highly sensitive to the annual decrease in incidence rates. The impact of ending the BCG schools scheme was found to be greater than previously thought when parameter values were updated and notification data were used. Our results highlight the importance of including uncertainty when forecasting the impact of changes in vaccination policy.\n\nWhat is already known on this subjectO_LITargeted Bacillus Calmette Guerin (BCG) vaccination against TB is recommended in low incidence countries over universal vaccination.\nC_LIO_LIThe impact of replacing universal BCG vaccination in England and Wales with a targeted programme in 2005 was assessed under the assumption of static declines in TB rates.\nC_LIO_LIThe BCG Guerin vaccine was shown to be effective in the UK born in England, regardless of the age at which it was given. School-age vaccination maybe more beneficial in this population than in other settings.\nC_LI\n\nWhat this study addsO_LIUsing notification data from England and Wales from 1973 to 2015, we estimate that the ending the BCG schools scheme likely resulted in more additional cases than was predicted.\nC_LIO_LIThe inclusion of parameter uncertainty, and measurement error, allowed the uncertainty in the final estimates to be presented. Previously published estimates may have been spuriously precise.\nC_LIO_LIThis study highlights the need for a more detailed evaluation of the 2005 change in BCG policy. In particular, the impact of including the introduction of targeted neonatal vaccination and capturing the long term, indirect, effects needs further study.\nC_LI

Explore related subjects

epidemiologyPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Abbott, S., Christensen, H., Brooks-Pollock, E.. 2019-05-03. Reassessing the Evidence for Universal School-age Bacillus Calmette Guerin (BCG) Vaccination in England and Wales. https://doi.org/10.1101/624916

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2019

Factors associated with cholera outbreaks, Nairobi County, July 2017: a case control study

BackgroundCholera affects 1.3-4 million people globally and causes 21000-143,000 deaths annually. Nairobi County in Kenya reported cholera cases since April 2017. We investigated to identify associated factors and institute control measures.\n\nMethodsWe reviewed the line-list of patients admitted at the Kenyatta National referral Hospital, Nairobi and performed descriptive epidemiology. We carried out a frequency-matched case control study, using facility-based cases and community controls. We defined a case as acute onset of watery diarrhoea of at least >3 stools/24hours with or without vomiting in person of any age, admitted in Kenyatta National Hospital as from July 1st, 2017. We calculated odds ratios and their respective 95% confidence intervals. We also took water samples at water reservoirs, distribution and consumer points, and made observation on hygiene and sanitation conditions in the community.\n\nResultsWe reviewed 71 line-listed cases; median age 30 years (range 2-86 years); 45 (63%) were male. First case was admitted on 14th April 2017. Culture was performed on 44 cases, 30 (68%) was positive for Vibrio cholerae, biotype El-Tor, serotype Ogawa. There were 2 deaths (case fatality ratio 2.8%). Age-group [≥]25 years was most affected. Drinking unchlorinated water (aOR 14.57, 95% CI 4.44-47.83), eating in public places (aOR 9.45, 95% CI 3.07-29.12) sourcing water from non-Nairobi city water company source (aOR 4.92, 95% CI 1.56-15.52) and having drank untreated water in the previous week before the outbreak (aOR 3.21, 95% CI 1.12-9.24) were independently associated with being a case in the outbreak. Out of 28 water samples, 4 (14%) had >180 coliforms/100mls; all were at consumer points.\n\nConclusionPoor water quality and sanitation were responsible for this outbreak. We recommended adequate, clean water supply to unplanned settlements in Nairobi County, as well education of residents on water treatment at the household level.\n\nAuthor summaryCholera, a disease causing outbreaks in areas with low standards of hygiene and sanitation has afflicted humans for millennia. It is caused by a bacterium, Vibrio Cholerae, transmitted mainly through water contaminated by faecal matter. The resultant disease is acute watery diarrhoea, which causes death rapidly due to dehydration and shock. Virtually brought under control in the developed world due to improvements in hygiene, the disease still ravages many communities in low and middle income countries, as well as regions affected by conflict or natural disasters. In outbreak situations, rapid response in water treatment, sanitation improvement and setting up of cholera treatment centres for rehydration therapy reduces impact and saves lives. Long-term control can only be achieved through sustainable improvements in sanitation and standards of living. Case control studies in outbreak situations provide quick, actionable information to public health specialists during outbreak response. This study provides a cholera outbreak investigation in an urban informal settlement setting; the approach reported here can guide in outbreak investigations and response in similar settings globally.

epidemiology↗
bioRxiv2019

Infection of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato of small mammals in Yunnan Province, China

BackgroundLyme disease is caused by Borrelia burgdorferisensulato (BBSL) which is usually found in wild and domestic mammals worldwide. Human cases of B. burgdorferi infections have been identified in China, but little direct surveillance of potential rodent reservoirs has been performed in Yunnan Province, Southwestern China. Yunnan Province is a tropical area with a diverse topographic range and sustains a high biodiversity of small mammals that could potentially play an important role in the transmission of a variety of B. burgdorferigenospecies.\n\nMethods3659 small mammals were captured in 159 sample siteslocated 23 countries inYunnan Province and screened for BBSL infection by nested PCR based on 5S-23S rRNA intergenic spacer gene of BBSL.Univariate and multivariate forward stepwise logistic regression analysis was used to access the association between infections and related risk factors.\n\nResultsInfection with BBSL was confirmed in 3.99%(146/3659) of small mammals. Significant differences in prevalence rates of BBSL were observed at varying landscape types and altitudes.Small mammals in forested areas had higher prevalence rates than other landscape types as did small mammals found at altitudes greater than 2500 meters. The 5S-23S rRNA intergenic spacergene revealed that there were 5 genotype of BBSL, including B. afzelii, B. burgdorferisensustricto, B.japonica, B.gariniiand B.valaisiana, which demonstrate the genetic diversity and regional distribution.\n\nConclusionsThere exists a wide distribution and genetic diversity of endemic BBSL in Southwestern China, warranting further investigations and monitoring of clinical disease in individuals presenting with symptoms of Lyme disease in these areas.\n\nAuthor summaryLyme disease is caused by Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato (BBSL) which is usually found in wild and domestic mammals worldwide. Human cases of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato infections have been identified in China, but little direct surveillance of potential rodent reservoirs has been performed in Southwestern China. This study documents potential small mammal reservoir hosts collected from a large of sample sites from different landscape types and altitudes, with PCR and sequencing identifying the wide distribution and genetic diversity of endemic Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato in Southwestern China. This was the first report that B. japonica was detected in Apodemus draco and Niviventer excelsior in China. This study adds to body of literature on Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato in China. This work will provide insight regarding small mammals to target for surveillance and we access the association between gender, developmental stage of rodents, environmental landscape and altitude to better prevent human exposure.

epidemiology↗
bioRxiv2019

Interdependence between confirmed and discarded cases of dengue, chikungunya and Zika viruses in Brazil: A multivariate time-series analysis

The co-circulation of different arboviruses in the same time and space poses a significant threat to public health given their rapid geographic dispersion and serious health, social, and economic impact. Therefore, it is crucial to have high quality of case registration to estimate the real impact of each arboviruses in the population. In this work, a Vector Autoregressive (VAR) model was developed to investigate the interrelationships between discarded and confirmed cases of dengue, chikungunya, and Zika in Brazil. We used data from the Brazilian National Notifiable Diseases Information System (SINAN) from 2010 to 2017. There were three peaks in the series of dengue notification in this period occurring in 2013, 2015 and in 2016. The series of reported cases of both Zika and chikungunya reached their peak in late 2015 and early 2016. The VAR model shows that the Zika series have a significant impact on the dengue series and vice versa, suggesting that several discarded and confirmed cases of dengue could actually have been cases of Zika. The model also suggests that the series of confirmed and discarded chikungunya cases are almost independent of the cases of Zika, however, affecting the series of dengue. In conclusion, co-circulation of arboviruses with similar symptoms could have lead to misdiagnosed diseases in the surveillance system. We argue that the routinely use of mathematical and statistical models in association with traditional symptom-surveillance could help to decrease such errors and to provide early indication of possible future outbreaks. These findings address the challenges regarding notification biases and shed new light on how to handle reported cases based only in clinical-epidemiological criteria when multiples arboviruses co-circulate in the same population. Author summaryArthropod-borne viruses (arboviruses) transmission is a growing health problem worldwide. The real epidemiological impact of the co-circulation of different arboviruses in the same urban spaces is a recent phenomenon and there are many issues to explore. One of them is the misclassification due to the scarce availability of confirmatory laboratory tests. This establishes a challenge to identify, distinguish and estimate the number of infections when different arboviruses co-circulate. We propose the use of multivariate time series analysis to understand how the weekly notification of suspected cases of dengue, chikungunya and Zika, in Brazil, affected each other. Our results suggest that the series of Zika significantly impact on the series of dengue and vice versa, indicating that several discarded and confirmed cases of dengue might actually have been Zika cases. The results also suggest that the series of confirmed cases of chikungunya are almost independent of those of dengue and Zika. Our findings shed light on yet hidden aspects on the co-circulation of these three viruses based on reported cases. We believe the present work provides a new perspective on the longitudinal analysis of arboviruses transmission and call attention to the challenge in dealing with biases in case notifications when multiple arboviruses circulate in the same urban environment.

epidemiology↗