Fin whale (Balaenoptera physalus) mitogenomics: A cautionary tale of defining sub-species from mitochondrial sequence monophyly

Cabrera, A. A.; Hoekendijk, J. P. A.; Aguilar, A.; Barco, S. G.; Berrow, S.; Bloch, D.; Borrell, A.; Cunha, H. A.; Dalla Rosa, L.; Dias, C. P.; Gauffier, P.; Hao, W.; Landry, S.; Larsen, F.; Martin, V.; Mizroch, S.; Oosting, T.; Oien, N.; Pampoulie, C.; Panigada, S.; Prieto, R.; Ramp, C.; Rivera-Leon, V. E.; Robbins, J.; Ryan, C.; Schall, E.; Sears, R.; Silva, M. A.; Urban, J.; Wenzel, F. W.; Palsboll, P. J.; Berube, M.

doi:10.1101/488130

Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/488130

Fin whale (Balaenoptera physalus) mitogenomics: A cautionary tale of defining sub-species from mitochondrial sequence monophyly

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

HighlightsO_LIMitochondrial monophyly is commonly employed to define evolutionary significant units.\nC_LIO_LIMonophyly may be caused by insufficient sampling or a recent common ancestor.\nC_LIO_LIMitogenomic studies are generally based on few samples and prone to sampling issues.\nC_LIO_LIExpanded mitogenome sampling negates previous monophyly in fin whales.\nC_LI\n\nAbstractThe advent of massive parallel sequencing technologies has resulted in an increase of studies based upon complete mitochondrial genome DNA sequences that revisit the taxonomic status within and among species. Spatially distinct monophyly in mitogenomic genealogies, i.e., the sharing of a recent common ancestor among con-specific samples collected in the same region has been viewed as evidence for subspecies. Several recent studies in cetaceans have employed this criterion to suggest subsequent intraspecific taxonomic revisions. We reason that employing intra-specific, spatially distinct monophyly at non-recombining, clonally inherited genomes is an unsatisfactory criterion for defining subspecies based upon theoretical (genetic drift) and practical (sampling effort) arguments. This point is illustrated by a re-analysis of a global mitogenomic assessment of fin whales, Balaenoptera physalus spp., published by Archer et al. (2013) which proposed to further subdivide the Northern Hemisphere fin whale subspecies, B. p. physalus. The proposed revision was based upon the detection of spatially distinct monophyly among North Atlantic and North Pacific fin whales in a genealogy based upon complete mitochondrial genome DNA sequences. The extended analysis conducted in this study (1,676 mitochondrial control region, 162 complete mitochondrial genome DNA sequences and 20 microsatellite loci genotyped in 358 samples) revealed that the apparent monophyly among North Atlantic fin whales reported by Archer et al. (2013) to be due to low sample sizes. In conclusion, defining sub-species from monophyly (i.e., the absence of para-or polyphyly) can lead to erroneous conclusions due to relatively \"trivial\" aspects, such as sampling. Basic population genetic processes (i.e., genetic drift and migration) also affect the time to most recent common ancestor and hence the probability that individuals in a sample are monophyletic.\n\n\n\nO_FIG O_LINKSMALLFIG WIDTH=200 HEIGHT=195 SRC=\"FIGDIR/small/488130v1_ufig1.gif\" ALT=\"Figure 1\">\nView larger version (28K):\norg.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1e38e54org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@9533eborg.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@183b5b5org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@eae09_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_FIG C_FIG

Source connections

Published article ↗

Explore related subjects

evolutionary biology Preprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Cabrera, A. A., Hoekendijk, J. P. A., Aguilar, A., Barco, S. G., Berrow, S., Bloch, D., Borrell, A., Cunha, H. A., Dalla Rosa, L., Dias, C. P., Gauffier, P., Hao, W., Landry, S., Larsen, F., Martin, V., Mizroch, S., Oosting, T., Oien, N., Pampoulie, C., Panigada, S., Prieto, R., Ramp, C., Rivera-Leon, V. E., Robbins, J., Ryan, C., Schall, E., Sears, R., Silva, M. A., Urban, J., Wenzel, F. W., Palsboll, P. J., Berube, M.. 2018-12-06. Fin whale (Balaenoptera physalus) mitogenomics: A cautionary tale of defining sub-species from mitochondrial sequence monophyly. https://doi.org/10.1101/488130

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

Global homeostatic forces shape the composition of a hyperdiverse tropical insect fauna

Despite comprising the bulk of terrestrial biodiversity, we know surprisingly little about insect faunas, particularly in the tropics. Here, we characterize the insect fauna of Madagascar, a global biodiversity hotspot, based on extensive DNA metabarcoding of Malaise trap and leaf litter samples. We estimate that the fauna comprises at least 250,000 species, only 5% of which are currently recorded. The ecological and taxonomic composition is surprisingly similar to that of temperate forests. We show that this is likely caused by global homeostatic forces shaping net diversification rates after colonization of Madagascar rather than by the composition of colonizing lineages. Features differing from temperate forests include the dearth of parasitoids and richness of beetles. Understanding the forces shaping these patterns is key in sustainable management of tropical insect faunas.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2026

Do divergent mitochondrial backgrounds alter the fate of nuclear alleles during hybridization and admixture?

Hybridization brings together genetic variation from different populations or species into admixed genomes. As selection sorts this variation, the fate of each allele is determined by its fitness effect in the new hybrid genomic background. Because mitochondrial genes coevolve with the nuclear genome, they may be especially sensitive to foreign nuclear backgrounds, making them potential "hot-spots" for hybrid incompatibilities. Here, we test whether selection against mitonuclear incompatibilities drives repeatable hybridization outcomes. Specifically, we experimentally evolved three sets of five populations of hybrid Drosophila melanogaster, each carrying the same nuclear chromosomes but paired with one of three increasingly divergent mitochondrial DNA backgrounds. We hypothesized that accumulated incompatibilities would result in different patterns of nuclear admixture among mitochondrial backgrounds. To test this, we tracked nuclear allele frequencies in all 15 populations by whole-genome sequencing at intermediate time points. After 25 generations, we observed that rapid genomic evolution produced a strikingly parallel mosaic of both nuclear ancestries, independent of mitochondrial background. Contrary to our hypothesis, we found no evidence that mitochondrial background1 shaped nuclear admixture, even for interspecific combinations. These results suggest that in species with large effective population sizes, efficient purifying selection limits the accumulation of mitonuclear incompatibilities, allowing selection on nuclear alleles to promote repeatable ancestry sorting immediately following hybridization.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2026

Body size cascades from Neodiprion sawfly hosts to Perilampid parasitoids: An investigation of sequential divergence

Ecological speciation drives diversity in plant-eating insect systems, but it may also generate parallel specialization in parasitoid associates in a cascading effect of "sequential divergence." However, sequential divergence has never been successfully identified in parasitoids of externally feeding insects. To address this gap, we consider the Pinus-Neodiprion-Perilampus neodiprioni system, where plant-associated, externally feeding Neodiprion demonstrate ecological divergence, as supported by body size as a magic trait in sympatric species. It seems possible that this body size differentiation may cascade to Neodiprion's parasitoids via sequential divergence. Therefore, we asked, "Does P. neodiprioni exhibit host-specific divergence in body size that parallels patterns in Neodiprion hosts?" Further, "Does P. neodiprioni exhibit host-related variation in the abdominal region or sexually dimorphic features, supporting reproductive barriers?" Using by-catch samples, we measured body size of P. neodiprioni, reared from Neodiprion lecontei and Neodiprion pinetum hosts. We analyzed body size variation as predicted by host species, parasitoid sex, host sex, host cocoon size, latitude, and their interactions. In addition, we used mixed models to analyze the effects of parasitoid sex and Neodiprion host on three size-based facial features. We found that P. neodiprioni demonstrates host-associated body size variation that mirrors size differences in their Neodiprion hosts. In addition, host-associated size variation occurs in the abdominal region and two sexually dimorphic characters of P. neodiprioni, supporting possible reproductive isolation. Together, these patterns suggest that host magic traits may drive not only within-species ecological divergence, but they can facilitate parasitoids' subsequent morphological differentiation and possible sequential divergence.

evolutionary biology↗