A congenital pain insensitivity mutation in the nerve growth factor gene uncouples nociception from affective pain in heterozygous humans and mice

Abstract

Pain is an unpleasant but necessary sensory experience, which facilitates adaptive behaviours, such as fear. Despite recent advances, the question of how the pain experience influences learning of the fear response is still debated1,2. Genetic disorders rendering patients congenitally unable to feel pain have been described, and are usually explained by defects in peripheral nociceptors3-5. It is not known how growing up without pain affects central emotional and motivational responses to aversive stimuli. The rare autosomal recessive Hereditary Sensory and Autonomic Neuropathy type V (HSAN V) is caused by a mutation in the nerve growth factor (NGF) gene (R100W). HSAN V homozygous patients display a congenital indifference to painful events, with deficits in peripheral nociceptors but without overt cognitive impairment6. In contrast, heterozygous carriers do not present with pain-related deficits and have been identified only through pedigree and genetic screening7,8. We exploited this clinically silent population to dissociate nociceptive from affective features of pain. To address this we investigated both heterozygous knock-in mice bearing the R100W mutation (NGFR100W/m mice) and a cohort of HSAN V heterozygous human carriers. Surprisingly, we found that NGFR100W/m mice, despite normal responses to a noxious conditioning stimulus, show a deficit in learned fear while their social and innate fear responses are normal. The lack of pain-related fear response was linked to a reduced activation of anterior cingulate and motor cortices and of striatum, but not in primary somatosensory cortex. Likewise, human heterozygous R100W carriers, despite perceiving noxious stimuli and reporting subjective pain thresholds, show increased reaction latencies in response to painful stimulation, alongside a decreased subjective urgency to react. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) revealed, comparably to the mouse data, an altered processing of painful stimuli in rostral anterior cingulate, medial premotor cortical regions and striatum. These findings from both human and mouse HSAN V carriers uncover behavioural and motivational consequences of a mild genetic pain insensitivity on the establishment of pain-dependent affective responses and memories.