Tradeoffs and cultural diversity

Abstract

Culture is humanitys prime adaptation. Which cultural traits contribute to adaptive value at the level of cultural groups, and how they do so, is, however, unclear and debated. Here, we apply an approach from systems biology, known as Pareto task inference (ParTI), to bring a fresh perspective to these questions. ParTI considers systems that need to perform multiple tasks. No system can be optimal at all tasks at once, leading to a fundamental tradeoff. These tradeoffs result in specific patterns in multivariate trait data: data falls inside polygons in trait space, whose vertices are trait combinations that are adaptive for each of the tasks. ParTI can infer the number of adaptive tasks and their nature without need for a-priori assumptions, based on the vertices of these polygons. Here, we applied ParTI to two datasets of cultural traits, on Austronesian cultures and modern hunter-gatherers, adjusting for phylogeny and spatial diffusion effects. We find evidence that these independent datasets show a tradeoff between the same three tasks. We identify the tasks as resource defense, resource competition, and mobility/exchange. Specific combinations of cultural traits are adaptive for each of these tasks. This approach can be widely applied to any large multivariate dataset to study trade-offs in cultural evolution.