PD-1 blockade during T cell priming enhances long-term protection against metastatic tumors by epigenetically tuning T cell exhaustion

Abstract

In cancer, CD8+ T cell responses are dominated by exhausted T cells, which can be reinvigorated using immune checkpoint blockade therapy and can control large tumors. However, it remains unclear which T cell fate best supports long-term immunity following tumor regression or clearance and a period of minimal antigen load. This question is particularly relevant following surgical tumor resection, when tuning the immune system could prevent recurrence. To determine which T cell fate provides durable protection following surgery and metastatic rechallenge, we modulated T cell priming using anti-PD-1, IFN-{beta} or agonistic anti-CD40 and assessed effects on CD8+ T cell differentiation and overall survival. IFN-{beta} and anti-CD40 promoted effector and memory-like T cell states, respectively, whereas anti-PD-1 did not markedly alter T cell differentiation, yet conferred the greatest survival benefit against metastatic tumors. Notably, anti-PD-1 induced epigenetic remodeling, which was detectable upon metastatic recall, consistent with the maintenance of a circulatory intermediate-exhausted T cell state. Thus, while effector and memory precursor-like T cells could be generated with IFN-{beta} and agonistic anti-CD40, only the intermediate-exhausted T cell state driven by anti-PD-1 supported durable anti-tumor immunity. SummaryThis study shows that PD-1 blockade during T cell priming promotes a circulatory intermediate-exhausted CD8 T cell state that uniquely supports durable anti-tumor immunity after surgical resection and metastatic challenge, outperforming effector or memory-like T cell responses generated by IFN-{beta} or CD40 agonist treatment, respectively.