Encoding without generation in the medial prefrontal cortex during cautious goal-directed actions

Abstract

Adaptive behavior under threat requires deciding when to act and when to withhold action to avoid harm, often under conditions where movement, arousal, and task demand covary. Medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) activity is widely associated with such control, yet it remains unclear whether this activity reflects causal action generation or broader evaluative processes shaped by behavioral state. Here, we combined fiber photometry, single-cell calcium imaging, mixed-effects modeling, and optogenetic inhibition to examine how GABAergic neurons in mouse mPFC represent cues, actions, and outcomes during a series of learned avoidance tasks of increasing complexity that promote cautious responding. By explicitly controlling for baseline activity and movement, we show that much apparent task-related activity in mPFC reflects movement and cue-evoked signals that are also present in a control cortical region, the visual cortex. mPFC GABAergic neurons showed little encoding of simple avoidance contingencies but broadly encoded punished outcomes. A small subset of neurons with strong movement sensitivity encoded more demanding avoidance contingencies requiring selection between action generation and deferment. For equivalent avoidance actions, distinct neuronal populations preferentially encoded either cue onset or the action. Despite this encoding, optogenetic inhibition of mPFC had minimal effects on the learning or performance of the different contingencies. These findings reveal a dissociation between neural encoding and causal necessity, indicating that mPFC GABAergic activity primarily reflects evaluative and contextual aspects of cautious avoidance behavior rather than direct control of action execution. Significance statementAvoiding danger often requires deciding when to act and when to hold back. The dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) is widely assumed to support this control, yet the contributions of its neurons have remained unclear. Using neural population and single-neuron recordings together with targeted inhibition in mice performing learned threat-guided tasks, we show that GABAergic mPFC neurons are activated by cues, actions, and outcomes, but are not required for executing the behavior itself. These findings suggest that the mPFC primarily evaluates and contextualizes threat-motivated actions rather than generating them, highlighting a common mismatch between neural encoding and causal necessity.