Contemporary HIV-1 envelope pseudovirus panels for detecting and assessing B cell lineages with broadly neutralizing antibody potential

Abstract

Although a protective HIV-1 vaccine has not yet been realized, significant progress has been made in vaccine designs that trigger B cell lineages with potential to produce broadly neutralizing antibodies (bnAbs). Advancing these strategies by optimizing vaccine boosting regimens requires early detection of maturing antibodies with neutralizing activity against native envelope glycoprotein (Env) trimers and streamlined strategies to identify antibodies as they begin to manifest desired levels of breadth and potency. Thus, we designed three types of pseudovirus screening panels based on Envs of contemporary HIV-1 isolates to facilitate detection of bnAb lineages that are on favorable trajectories during a vaccination course. The panels were selected from Tier 2 Transmitted Founder Lineage (TFL) HIV-1 Envs from placebo participants in the Antibody Mediated Prevention (AMP) efficacy trials. Using 15 bnAbs to evaluate the neutralization sensitivity of the viruses, we selected 8-member bnAb class-specific panels most sensitive to bAbs representing their class: V2-apex, V3-glycan, CD4-receptor binding site (CD4bs), Membrane-Proximal External Region (MPER), or fusion peptide (FP). Next, we combined the most sensitive viruses among the class-specific panels to create a 12-virus panel to enable optimal detection of low-titer bnAb activity across epitope specificities. Finally, as HIV-1 continues to evolve greater levels of antigenic diversity and as current global pseudoviruses bnAb panels rely on viruses collected more than twenty years ago, we showed the importance of using contemporary viral panels to assess bnAb breadth and potency and designed a 12-virus panel representative of the spectrum neutralization profiles among AMP placebo viruses. We characterized pseudoviruses bearing each selected Env using standardized human sera to confirm their Tier 2 status and biological relevance. These updated panels enable sensitive screening of neutralization activity in vaccine studies and can also provide a realistic assessment of the expected breadth and potency of maturing responses against contemporary HIV-1 Envs. AUTHOR SUMMARYA primary goal of HIV-1 vaccine research is to elicit neutralizing antibodies that can prevent infection, but HIV-1 is highly variable and so stimulating responses that can work effectively against the diverse array of HIV-1 variants remains an unsolved challenge. However, the HIV-1 vaccine field has made significant progress in terms of stimulating B cell lineages that produce antibodies known to have features able to ultimately generate potent broadly neutralizing antibodies. Inducing such precursor B cells is just the first step, as B cells need evolve in response to an antigenic stimulus through a process called affinity maturation to acquire potency and breadth against the natural diversity of circulating HIV-1 strains. The next step is to discover and optimize vaccine strategies that will selectively induce such maturation. To facilitate this work, we have designed panels of biologically relevant, contemporary HIV-1 Envelope pseudotyped viruses that will enable sensitive detection of neutralizing antibodies in human and animal vaccine studies. We also have defined a small screening panel intended to provide a quick but realistic assessment of the potential of a vaccine-stimulated antibody response or a monoclonal antibody being evaluated for clinical use to effectively counter and block currently circulating HIV-1 variants.