Search bioRxiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2025.11.09.687451

Validating folding energy estimates as a method for variant interpretation

Elwes, C.·Alcraft, R.·Lister, H.·Smith, P. A.·Shorthouse, D.·Hall, B. A.
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Interpretation of variants of uncertain significance remains a major problem in genomic analysis. Whilst statistical models can be used to predict pathogenicity, they offer no insights into the biophysical mechanism of variant action, and genomic data available for training is biased towards the subpopulations who have access. Protein misfolding has been found to act as a frequent mechanism for loss of gene or domain activity, where it is typically responsible for [~]2/3 of disease-causing variants and somatic mutations. The accuracy of energy predictions however has consistently been challenged by highly variable correlation coefficients reported from different proteins, and the unknown impact of alternative structures where available. Here we address this directly through a systematic analysis of mega-scale folding experimental results, enabled by a fully automated predictive pipeline based on FoldX. We find that whilst absolute correlation coefficients are mediocre for three highly studied proteins (0.30-0.31), the correlation coefficient alone does not capture the full predictive power of the estimates. Specifically, we find a clear linear relationship between experimental and theoretical result, with a small number of outlier residues responsible for reducing the correlation. We show that the quantitative accuracy of predictions can be improved by aggregating estimates taken from different structures, and that the problematic outlier residues can be both empirically and theoretically identified, allowing us to flag low-confidence values. Our findings not only provide a framework for identifying problematic mutations in advance but also offers new insights into potential improvements of the FoldX protocol for more accurate protein stability predictions. Our insights support the use of FoldX in computational saturation screens to support variant analysis.

Explore related subjects

biophysicsPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Elwes, C., Alcraft, R., Lister, H., Smith, P. A., Shorthouse, D., Hall, B. A.. 2025-11-10. Validating folding energy estimates as a method for variant interpretation. https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.11.09.687451

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

Expression-System Biases Compromise the Functional Assessment of KCNH2 Variants and Clinical Risk Assessment

Background: Functional characterization of KCNH2 variants is essential for assessing pathogenicity in long QT syndrome type 2. Because hERG channels assemble as tetramers, the relative expression of wild-type (WT) and variant subunits critically influences channel function and pathogenicity assessment. However, commonly used experimental systems may not reproduce the balanced allelic expression observed in heterozygous patients. Methods: Allele-specific KCNH2 expression was analyzed in two independent RNA-sequencing datasets from human left ventricular tissue. Using the dominant-negative T74R hERG variant as a model, we calibrated the relationship between WT-to-variant expression ratios and hERG current amplitude. Using automated patch-clamp electrophysiology, we compared 3 dual-expression strategies: internal ribosome entry site (IRES), P2A-linked tandem constructs, and dual cytomegalovirus promoter (dCMV) constructs. Co-electroporation of WT and variant plasmids in different ratios was the reference. Results: Allele-specific expression analysis supported balanced KCNH2 expression in human left ventricular tissue. At a 1:1 WT-to-T74R expression ratio, hERG current amplitude was reduced to 31.0% of WT, consistent with a dominant-negative mechanism in which incorporation of 2 or more T74R subunits renders the channel nonfunctional. All 3 dual-expression strategies produced substantial expression imbalances, with the first cassette consistently favored. IRES constructs showed the greatest asymmetry. P2A constructs partially improved expression balance but introduced an additional N-terminal proline in the second cassette altering T74R-associated trafficking and channel biophysics. The dCMV system also failed to achieve balanced expression, including after stable integration. Co-electroporation of separate WT and variant plasmids provided the most reliable means of controlling their relative expression. Conclusions: Commonly used dual-expression constructs do not reliably reproduce balanced WT and variant hERG expression, potentially distorting assessments of dominant-negative effects and variant pathogenicity. Co-electroporation of separate plasmids provides a robust approach for high-throughput functional phenotyping under heterozygous conditions, with implications for the interpretation of KCNH2 variants and potentially other genes encoding multimeric ion channels.

biophysics↗
bioRxiv2026

Learning from Hi-C reveals nuclear dynamical reorganization in budding yeast across the cell cycle

Hi-C contact maps provide population-averaged measurements of chromosomal contacts. Converting these measurements, however, into three-dimensional structures and associated dynamics remains an underdetermined problem. Existing approaches broadly fall into two classes. Data-driven reconstruction methods that infer either a consensus structure or an ensemble of conformations, but do not inform on chromosome dynamics. Physics-based models, which generate dynamical trajectories, but require prior assumptions about nuclear geometry, chromatin mechanics, tethering, or molecular interactions. Here, we bridge these approaches using the Full-Inversion Chromatin model, a data-driven whole-genome polymer framework that learns an effective force field directly from Hi-C contact probabilities, integrated with Serpentine, a tool to quantify contact-map discrepancies while accounting for differences in sequencing coverage and sparsity. This generates structural ensembles of chromosomes and effective chromatin dynamics. We apply this method at 5-kb resolution to Saccharomyces cerevisiae in G1, mid-S, S/G2, G2/M, anaphase, and quiescence. Without explicitly imposing the spindle pole body, centromere or telomere tethering, predefined chromatin states, or nuclear-envelope interactions, the inferred ensembles recover these major features of yeast nuclear organization. Importantly, although dynamical information is not used during model training, the resulting polymer trajectories reproduce the subdiffusive scaling and chromosomal variations of independently measured chromatin motion. The model further predicts heterogeneous mobility along chromosomes and a distinctive telomere-dependent dynamical organization. Thus, population-averaged Hi-C contacts contain sufficient information to infer not only three-dimensional genome organization, but also effective, locus-dependent chromatin dynamics.

biophysics↗
bioRxiv2026

One high-order ion-coupling mechanism generates multiple SLC1A stoichiometries

Human excitatory amino acid transporter 2 (hEAAT2) is a glial transporter that clears glutamate and aspartate from the extracellular space to terminate neurotransmission. When this essential role is disrupted, excess extracellular glutamate causes excitotoxicity and neurological disease. hEAAT2 transports amino acids into cells against their concentration gradients by coupling uptake to the co-transport of Na+ and H+, and counter-transport of K+. Substrate transport also activates a thermodynamically uncoupled Cl- conductance, whose significance is unknown. Here, to dissect the molecular mechanisms underlying coupled and uncoupled ion transport by EAATs, we leverage the tractable Drosophila melanogaster homologue dEAAT2, which transports taurine as well as glutamate and aspartate. By functionally characterising dEAAT2, we confirmed it has features of a canonical EAAT transport cycle, including an uncoupled Cl- conductance. However, it functions an ion-independent electroneutral exchanger, in stark contrast to its ion-coupled electrogenic human counterpart. Cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and computational simulations confirmed the inability of dEAAT2 to transport cations, but just two point mutations conferred Na+, H+, and K+ dependence, reconstituting the complex ion coupling profile of human transporters in the Drosophila exchanger. We also showed that dEAAT2 transports taurine in a complex with Cl-, bestowing a unique Cl--dependence on taurine transport, independent of uncoupled Cl- flux. Our findings show that ancestral exchangers in the EAAT family preserve the machinery to achieve complex ion-coupled transport, revealing the molecular basis of high-order ion coupling in hEAATs.

biophysics↗