Pair-Living Emerged Early in Placental Mammals

Abstract

It is widely assumed that the first placental mammals were solitary. This assumption has been used as the default in previous comparative studies, but has never been tested independently. Here, we compiled a comprehensive database by reviewing over 14,000 primary peer-reviewed publications on the social organization of the 5,386 extant placental mammal species. We found empirical data for 738 species across 1,478 populations: 354 populations were primarily solitary, 241 populations pair-living and 878 populations group-living. Notably, 383 species (52%) and 580 populations (39%) exhibited intra-specific variation in social organization. Using a Bayesian phylogenetic framework that incorporates intra-specific variation, we show that the ancestral placental mammal - living approximately 160 to 100 million years ago - was not exclusively solitary, but likely displayed intraspecific variation. Pair-living was predicted to account for approximately 26% of ancestral social organisation. Our analysis found that ecology and life history of extant solitary and pair-living mammals was very similar and different from those of group-living mammals. Our results revise prevailing theories of mammalian social evolution, revealing that pair-living emerged early, shifting the focus of mammalian social evolution from the origins of pair-living to the origins of group-living.