Overcoming breeding constraints in polyploid oat from evolutionary insights

Abstract

Polyploidy provides adaptive advantages in plants by buffering deleterious mutations1,2. While polyploidization can enhance agronomic traits such as increased biomass, known as the gigas effect1-4, increasing genetic gain in polyploid crops remains a critical but difficult goal due to the difficulty in dissecting complex trait inheritance5,6. Here we present chromosome-scale genome assemblies for 26 Avena taxa, spanning diploid, tetraploid, and hexaploid lineages. We traced four independent polyploidization events across the genus, including the formation of A. agadiriana as an allotetraploid (AgAgAg'Ag'), and revealed a reticulate evolutionary history shaped by gene flow involving four subgenomes (A, B, C, D), for example, the hybrid speciation of A. hirtula. Transcriptomic analysis of 286 samples across 11 tissues, combined with deleterious mutation analysis from a cultivated population of 112 accessions, showed that polyploidization led to widespread functional redundancy among homoeologs, supporting a genome-wide buffering effect. However, derived allele frequency analysis revealed that, while disrupting functional genes may yield desirable traits, the buffering effect impedes the fixation of beneficial loss-of-function mutations and thereby limits breeding efficiency. Based on these integrative analyses, we propose breeding strategies to circumvent these limitations by targeting beneficial loss-of-function alleles within the complex polyploid background of oat. Our study highlights broader challenges in the improvement of polyploid crops and provides a foundation for future breeding strategies.