Worldwide spread of Hylurgus ligniperda (Coleoptera: Scolytinae), and the potential role of bridgehead invasions

Abstract

Hylurgus ligniperda (F.) is a highly successful invader among bark beetles (Scolytinae) and forest insects in general. Native to the western Palearctic region, it has become established in every continent where its host plants (Pinus spp.) occur. Especially in southern hemisphere regions with large pine plantations, it is often highly abundant. As a repeat invader with a wealth of information on various aspects relevant for biological invasions, it is highly suitable as a model organism for studying the role of international trade, the planting of non-native trees, and the potential occurrence of bridgehead invasions (where abundant non-native populations precipitate further invasions). In the present study, our specific objectives were to reconstruct the worldwide invasions of H. ligniperda and the pathways involved by using a multi-pronged approach including population genetics, analysis of historic interception data generated from inspections of imports, and records of establishments in the literature. Our review of the native and non-native ranges of H. ligniperda and the chronology of establishments revealed at least 13 separate invasions of non-native regions, beginning with Madeira (Portugal) before 1850, and, most recently, eastern China in 2019. We compared the population genetics of 464 specimens from eight countries in the native range and eight countries in the non-native range. Sequencing of the mitochondrial COI gene revealed the presence of 29 haplotypes in six well-supported clades, based on a Bayesian analysis. Non-native populations had significantly lower haplotype diversity (mean h = 0.219) than populations in the native range (mean h = 0.691). Countries in the non-native range had an average of about two haplotypes compared with about four haplotypes in native countries. In the non-native range, only one or two haplotypes were dominant, and these differed among invaded regions except for haplotype HL-H3 which occurred in Australia, New Zealand and China as well as in four countries in southern Europe, and HL-H4 which was dominant in New Zealand, California, New York State, and eastern China as well as two countries in southern Europe. Analyses of interceptions of H. ligniperda with imports arriving in five countries revealed that between 74% and 99% of interceptions originated from other non-native regions while in the USA, most interceptions were linked to imports from the native range beginning in the 1970s. Based on the combined evidence of the chronology of invasions, interception data, and analysis of haplotype distribution, we conclude that the early invasions (before 1950) probably all originated from the native range, while several of the more recent invasions probably originated from parts of the non-native range (suggestive of a bridgehead effect). However, it cannot be determined with certainty what the original sources of each of the invading populations were.