Search bioRxiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2024.07.07.602370

Library size can undermine accurate molecular and phenotypic subtyping in spatial transcriptomics data.

Fisher, N. C.·Malla, S. B.·Jamieson, N.·Dunne, P. D.
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

In an era where transcriptomics-based subtyping, phenotyping and mechanistic understanding is increasingly being driven by state-of-the-art spatially resolved transcriptomic (ST) technologies, it is imperative that researchers, journals, and funders do all they can to ensure that as a community we are interpreting these exciting data as accurately as possible with awareness of their limitations. In this short report, we highlight one potential bias in ST data that could undermine accurate interpretation of transcriptional signatures, providing the field with an opportunity to identify and avoid this issue prior to release of new mechanistic findings. This issue is particularly relevant for platforms that produce some of the most granular and high-resolution spatial information at single cell (and sub-cellular) resolution, with the compromise of a reduced transcriptome panel of genes (Figure 1A). O_FIG O_LINKSMALLFIG WIDTH=141 HEIGHT=200 SRC="FIGDIR/small/602370v1_fig1.gif" ALT="Figure 1"> View larger version (42K): org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1219fb3org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@7bd4a4org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1c55c42org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@2bf924_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_FIG O_FLOATNOFigure 1.C_FLOATNO Visualisation of the iCMS3 up signature A: Schematic overview of enrichment using a full gene panel versus a reduced panel. B: Overlap between the genes represented on the CosMx and Xenium gene panels. C: Correlation between the single sample scores of the full iCMS3 up signature (74 genes) and the 15 genes from the signature represented on the CosMx platform. Two samples are highlighted which have a similar iCMS3 up enrichment for the full signature (CRC-JSC-S06: 4535.746; SMC16: 4265.263) but extreme enrichments for the signature composed only of the genes present on the CosMx array (CRC-JSC-S06: 301.0396; SMC16: 11430.593). Median (4047.994) shown by red line. D: Visualisation of the rank of each sample across for the full (CRC-JSC-S06: position 25872/44458; SMC16: position 23907/44458) and CosMx (CRC-JSC-S06: position 513/44458; SMC16: position 44241/44458) signature enrichment. E: Heatmap showing the relative enrichment of each gene with the iCMS3 up signature for each sample, with the genes present on the CosMx array in red. F: Subset of samples (n=628) +/-1% of the median (4007.514 - 4088.474), with the top 100 and bottom 100 samples for CosMx enrichment in red. G: Heatmap of the top 100 and bottom 100 samples (shown in red in F) for CosMx enrichment with a full iCMS3 up enrichment around the median. The samples are arranged by the rank of each sample for CosMx signature enrichment, with the sum of the genes within the iCMS3 up signature present on the array (CosMx [n=16]) and those not present on the array (Non CosMx [n=58]) overlaid as barplots. C_FIG

Explore related subjects

cancer biologyPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Fisher, N. C., Malla, S. B., Jamieson, N., Dunne, P. D.. 2024-07-07. Library size can undermine accurate molecular and phenotypic subtyping in spatial transcriptomics data.. https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.07.602370

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

Ex vivo human tumor slices more accurately predict patient responses to an oncolytic virus than in vivo mouse models

Immunotherapies, including oncolytic viruses (OV), are promising therapies that can enhance anti-tumor immune responses. However, preclinical success of immunotherapies in mouse models has not always translated to clinical benefit in cancer patients. This study compared preclinical efficacy and mechanism of action for ASP9801, a vaccinia virus expressing IL-7 and IL-12, using mouse models of colorectal cancer (CRC) in vivo and in human organotypic tumor slice models ex vivo. The murine surrogate for ASP9801 significantly reduced tumor volumes in treated and abscopal tumors in two different CRC models in vivo (MC38 and RO100). Treatment efficacy was accentuated when combined with anti-PD1 treatment, and single-cell RNA sequencing analysis revealed depletion of tumor cells and increased T cell infiltration and activation in both treated and abscopal tumors. However, human tissue analysis ex vivo (E-slices) using PDX models and patient samples showed that ASP9801 is not effective in CRC, consistent with clinical trial results. On the other hand, ASP9801 was highly effective in GBM, indicating indication-specific efficacy of ASP9801, and how E-slice assays can be used to identify treatment-sensitive indications. This study demonstrates the superiority of E-slices over mouse models for predicting clinical response and its utility in planning clinical trials.

cancer biology↗
bioRxiv2026

Immune-cell depleted diffuse large B-cell lymphomas have reduced expression of MHC class I

Immunotherapy has transformed treatment for many cancers. In the aggressive and genetically heterogeneous diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL), CD19 CAR T-cell therapy is highly effective, whereas immune checkpoint blockade has shown limited benefit. Loss of MHC expression is a common mechanism to escape T-cell cytotoxicity, and loss of MHC class I (MHC-I) and II are frequent in DLBCL. We applied imaging mass cytometry to diagnostic biopsies from younger, high-risk DLBCL patients to map the tumor microenvironment (TME) spatial architecture in relation to tumor cell MHC expression, mutational status, transcriptomic and proteomic profiles. Neighborhood analyses identified four TME subtypes: immune-cell depleted and three immune-infiltrated types (mixed, CD4 T cell-rich, CD8 T-cell/macrophage-rich). Depleted cases had shorter overall survival (p = 0.033) and increased expression of proteins involved in DNA replication and proliferation markers compared to infiltrated cases. Tumor cell MHC-I expression was heterogeneous. Cases with low frequency of MHC-I-pos tumor cells were enriched for the depleted TME type. MHC-I-pos tumor cells were surrounded by CD4 and CD8 T cells and M1 macrophages, whereas MHC-I-neg tumor cells were closer to other MHC-I-neg tumor cells. These findings suggest that TME-based classification incorporating tumor cell MHC-I status may improve individualized immunotherapy selection.

cancer biology↗
bioRxiv2026

Cross-species analysis links cell-cell communication rewiring to NOTCH2 during serous endometrial carcinogenesis

Cell-cell interactions shape the fate of mutant cells during cancer initiation but how these interactions evolve during progression to pathologically recognizable lesions remain poorly understood. Here, we investigated cell-cell communication during serous endometrial carcinoma (SEC; also known as uterine serous carcinoma) development using a lineage-traceable mouse model and cross-species analyses of the mouse and human neoplastic endometrium. In mice, the early, pre-dysplastic stage was marked by a global decrease in inferred cell-cell interactions, followed by extensive communication network rewiring during neoplastic progression. Pathway-specific analysis revealed a similar pattern for NOTCH signaling, with NOTCH2 emerging as the dominant NOTCH receptor in Trp53/Rb1-mutant immature epithelial cells. Functionally, NOTCH2 promoted the outgrowth of more proliferative mutant organoids. Cross-species transcriptomic analysis identified conserved immature epithelial states in mouse and human neoplastic endometrial epithelium. In human tissues, NOTCH2 was overexpressed in serous endometrial intraepithelial carcinoma, a precursor of SEC, and in overt SEC. Furthermore, elevated NOTCH2 expression was associated with poor patient survival. These findings link cell-cell communication rewiring during experimental SEC development to conserved neoplastic epithelial states and identify NOTCH2 as an early marker and a potential target of disease interception.

cancer biology↗