Cytomegalovirus inhibitors of programmed cell death prevent a contribution of antigen cross-presentation to the priming of antiviral CD8 T cells

Abstract

CD8 T cells are the predominant effector cells of adaptive immunity in preventing cytomegalovirus (CMV) multiple-organ disease caused by cytopathogenic tissue infection. The mechanism by which CMV-specific, naive CD8 T cells become primed and clonally expand is of fundamental importance for our understanding of CMV immune control. For CD8 T-cell priming, two pathways have been identified: direct antigen presentation by infected professional antigen-presenting cells (pAPCs) and antigen cross-presentation by uninfected pAPCs that take up antigenic material derived from infected tissue cells. Studies in mouse models using murine CMV (mCMV) and precluding either pathway genetically or experimentally have shown that, in principle, both pathways can congruently generate the mouse MHC/H-2 class-I-determined epitope-specificity spectrum of the CD8 T-cell response. Own recent studies, however, have shown that direct antigen presentation is the canonical pathway when both are accessible. This raised the question of why antigen cross-presentation is ineffective even under conditions of high virus replication thought to provide high amounts of antigenic material for feeding cross-presenting pAPCs. As delivery of antigenic material for cross-presentation is associated with programmed cell death, and as CMVs encode inhibitors of different cell death pathways, we pursued the idea that these inhibitors restrict antigen delivery and thus CD8 T-cell priming by cross-presentation. To test this hypothesis, we compared the CD8 T-cell responses to recombinant mCMVs lacking expression of the apoptosis-inhibiting protein M36 or the necroptosis-inhibiting protein M45 with responses to wild-type mCMV and revertant viruses expressing the respective cell death inhibitors. The data reveal that increased programmed cell death caused by deletion of either M36 or M45 improves CD8 T-cell priming in mice capable of antigen cross-presentation but not in a mutant mouse strain unable to cross-present. These findings strongly support the conclusion that CMV cell death inhibitors restrict the priming of CD8 T cells by antigen cross-presentation. Author SummaryIn patients as well as in experimental mouse models, CD8 T cells represent the most potent antiviral effector cells in preventing CMV disease in immunocompromised recipients of hematopoietic cell transplantation. Despite the clinical relevance of mounting a protective response, the mode of CMV antigen presentation to naive CD8 T cells remained unclear. In principle, naive CD8 T cells can be sensitized through "direct antigen presentation" on the surface of infected professional antigen-presenting cells (pAPCs) or through "antigen cross-presentation" by uninfected pAPCs that take up antigenic material derived from infected cells following cell death. As CMVs are cytopathogenic, eventually killing their host cells, and as they encode immune evasion proteins interfering with the MHC/HLA class-I pathway of direct antigen presentation in infected cells, it was reasonable to propose a dominant role for antigen cross-presentation. Mouse models precluding either pathway, however, revealed that both can raise an equivalent CD8 T-cell response, and recent work has identified direct antigen presentation as the canonical pathway taken when both are accessible. Here we show that virus-encoded inhibitors of two programmed cell death modalities, apoptosis and necroptosis, prevent an antigen release sufficient for a notable cross-presentation. This answers a long-debated open question in CMV immunology.