Vanillin flavor in e-liquids does not induce endothelial cell dysfunction: the Replica Project

Abstract

BackgroundThere are challenges that require collaboration among researchers to ensure that tobacco harm reduction strategies are evidence-based. One key challenge is evaluating the safety of flavors used in electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes). While many flavorings are approved as food additives or deemed "generally recognized as safe" (GRAS) for ingestion, this does not guarantee their safety when inhaled. In this context, the international research group Replica replicated a study conducted by Fetterman and colleagues in 2018, investigating the effects of aerosolized vanillin - one of the most popular flavors in vaping - on vascular endothelium when vaporized by an electronic cigarette. MethodsWe used Aspire Zelos 3 e-cigarette and prepared e-liquids containing propylene glycol, vegetable glycerin and vanillin. The e-liquids were vaporized under two settings - regular (1 ohm coil using wattage control mode at 14 watts) and sub-ohm (0.3 ohm coil using temperature control mode at 200 {degrees}C) - using a vaping machine, following the standardized puffing regime, ISO20768:2018. The vapor was then collected into a trapping solution to prepare aqueous extracts for the treatment of human aortic endothelial cells. We evaluated cytotoxicity, oxidative stress, nitric oxide bioavailability, and inflammation addressing some gaps reported in the original study. ResultsWe observed some harmful effects, mostly attributable to ethanol, used to dilute vanillin in the original work by Fetterman, but no harmful effects on cell viability, their ability to produce nitric oxide, or oxidative stress from vanillin. Furthermore, no pro-inflammatory effects of vanillin were observed in terms of ICAM-1 and IL-6 gene expression. ConclusionsOur results confirm the endothelial cell dysfunction observed in the original paper, but clarify that these effects are mainly attributable to ethanol and not to vaporized vanillin. These findings suggest that vanillin could be a safer flavoring agent for e-cigarette, without causing adverse effects on the cardiovascular system.