Eccentric exercise is not equal to eccentric contraction

Abstract

Whether eccentric exercise involves active fascicle stretch is unclear due to muscle-tendon unit (MTU) series elasticity. Therefore, this study investigated the impact of changing the activation timing and level (i.e., pre-activation) on muscle fascicle kinematics and kinetics of the human tibialis anterior during dynamometer-controlled maximal voluntary MTU-stretch-hold contractions. B-mode ultrasound and surface electromyography were employed to assess muscle fascicle kinematics and muscle activity levels, respectively. While joint kinematics were similar for MTU-stretch-hold contractions, increasing pre-activation increased fascicle shortening and stretch amplitudes (9.9 - 23.2 mm, p [≤] 0.015). This led to increasing positive and negative fascicle work with increasing pre-activation. Despite significantly different fascicle kinematics, similar peak fascicle forces during stretch occurred at similar fascicle lengths and joint angles regardless of pre-activation. Similarly, residual force enhancement (rFE) following MTU stretch was not significantly affected (6.5-7.6 %, p = 0.559) by pre-activation, but rFE was strongly correlated with peak fascicle force during stretch (rrm = 0.62, p = 0.003). These findings highlight that apparent eccentric exercise causes shortening-stretch contractions at the fascicle level rather than isolated eccentric contractions. The constant rFE despite different fascicle kinematics and kinetics suggests that a passive element was engaged at a common muscle length among conditions (e.g., optimal fascicle length). Although it remains unclear whether different fascicle mechanics trigger different adaptations to eccentric exercise, this study emphasizes the need to consider MTU series elasticity to better understand the mechanical drivers of adaptation to exercise. New & NoteworthyApparent eccentric exercises do not result in isolated eccentric contractions, but shortening-stretch contractions at the fascicle level. The amount of fascicle shortening and stretch depend on the pre-activation during the exercise and cannot be estimated from the muscle-tendon unit or joint kinematics. As different fascicle mechanics might trigger different adaptations to eccentric exercise, muscle-tendon unit series elasticity and muscle pre-activation need to be considered when eccentric exercise protocols and designed and evaluated.