Impacts of mate quality on female intrasexual aggression in two sister Malurus fairywren species

Abstract

In a large and ever-growing number of animal species, it is now appreciated that females use colors as a visual signal in a range of social interactions, including both courtship and territorial aggression. Yet, it remains unclear whether female color phenotypes and/or aggressive behaviors are correlated with any attributes of their mates phenotype. For example, we might expect species in which males contribute more to parental care or territorial defense to have more colorful or aggressive females. On the other hand, within species, we might expect those females mated to higher quality males to be more colorful or aggressive than those mated to lower quality males. To begin to address these possibilities, we conducted a preliminary study in two sister taxa of fairywren (Maluridae) with distinct life-history strategies and plumage dichromatism: white-shouldered fairywrens (Malurus alboscapulatus moretoni) in tropical Papua New Guinea, a species in which both males and females have ornamented plumage and jointly defend territories year-round, and red-backed fairywrens (M. melanocephalus melanocephalus) in temperate Australia, a sexually dichromatic species with ornamented males and unornamented females. At the between species level, we predicted white-shouldered fairywren females would be more aggressive in same-sex interactions than red-backed fairywrens, as both white-shouldered males contribute to year-round territorial defense, whereas territories break-down during non-breeding in red-backed fairywrens. Further, we predicted that, within species, females mated to males of higher quality would be more aggressive in simulated same-sex encounters. Between species, female white-shouldered fairywrens were more aggressive on average than female red-backed fairywrens as predicted. Within both species, indices of male quality were not related to female aggression (although there was a non-significant tendency for more aggressive female white-shouldered fairywren to have heavier mates with longer tails). These results point to a need for additional research exploring relationships between life history, female plumage, and female aggressive behaviors in a wider range of species.