When multi-voxel pattern similarity and global activation are intertwined: Approaches to disentangling correlation from activation

Abstract

Pattern similarity analysis, which uses correlation to examine similarities between neural activation patterns evoked by different trials or conditions, is often leveraged to test hypotheses not easily answerable with univariate comparisons, such as how events are represented or processed and the relationships between representations or processing of events. In principle, univariate analyses of global activation and multivariate analyses of pattern similarity can be used to answer substantively different questions about psychological and neural processing. For this to hold, it is necessary that pattern similarity estimates are not contaminated by differences in global activation across experimental events. Here, we report simulated data that demonstrate that global activation and pattern similarity (as assessed by correlation), although theoretically independent, are often intertwined. We present two plausible scenarios that illustrate how condition-specific changes in global activation can elicit condition-specific increases in pattern similarity by interacting with underlying across-voxel activation patterns. First, we consider a scenario in which a target region contains subpopulations of voxels such that only some voxels in a region are sensitive to a psychological variable and the remaining voxels are not modulated by this variable. In this scenario, this spatial pattern of responsive and unresponsive voxels adds new, shared across-voxel variability for events in the active condition, thereby increasing pattern similarity between these events. Second, we consider a scenario in which trials from all conditions elicit a shared across-voxel pattern of activation, but this shared across-voxel pattern is amplified for trials within one condition due to greater global activation. In this scenario, the change in activation for a given condition increases the ability to detect pre-existing, shared across-voxel variability across events in that condition, thereby increasing pattern similarity between these events. Given the observed influence of global activation on pattern similarity, we then assess whether it is possible to statistically separate the contributions of global activation and pattern similarity to observed activation patterns (using regression approaches, matching activation across conditions, and inclusion of control conditions). Additional simulations demonstrate that use of these techniques is not always effective in removing the influence of global activation on pattern similarity --the efficacy of these techniques depends on a variety of signal parameters that will likely vary across experiments and participants, highlighting the need for tailored control analyses that are targeted at addressing the particular hypotheses and potential global activation confounds of a given experiment. [Note: The reported simulations and this resulting white paper were generated in 2014. We share, without update, this paper given the continued relevance of understanding and controlling for global activation confounds when conducting multi-variate pattern analyses.]