Search bioRxiv⌕ Search

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2022.06.07.495188

Lake Erie fish safe to eat yet afflicted by algal hepatotoxins

Abstract

Microcystin toxins from harmful algal blooms (HABs) can accumulate and persist in fish, raising dual concerns about human health risks from consumption and the potential for detrimental impacts on fish populations. However, there are fundamental unknowns about the relationship between HABs and fish populations driven by a lack of field information on toxin accumulation and retention over space and time. We conducted a field study to assess human health risks from consuming fish caught across all life stages of a HAB and to determine the pervasiveness of potentially harmful levels of microcystins on fish populations. We collected 190 fish in 2015 and 2017 from Lake Erie, a large freshwater ecosystem that is highly productive for fisheries and is an epicenter of HABs and microcystin toxicity events. Muscles and livers were analyzed for total microcystins, which was used to conduct a human health risk assessment for comparison against fish consumption advisory benchmarks available for Lake Erie. We find low human health risk from muscle consumption following the World Health Organizations safety thresholds. However, all fish across capture dates had microcystins in their livers at levels shown to cause adverse effects, suggesting a pervasive and underappreciated toxic stressor. These data demonstrate that microcystins are retained in fish livers well beyond the cessation of HABs and calls for additional research to better understand the effects of sublethal toxic exposures for fish population dynamics, conservation, and related ecosystem services.

Source connections

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Shahmohamadloo, R. S., Bhavsar, S. P., Ortiz Almirall, X., Marklevitz, S. A. C., Rudman, S. M., Sibley, P. K.. 2022-06-09. Lake Erie fish safe to eat yet afflicted by algal hepatotoxins. https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.06.07.495188

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

Identifying key biodiversity areas in Mozambique for conservation planning and policy

The world is experiencing unprecedented rates of biodiversity loss. To reverse this trend, signatories to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) have committed to conserving at least 30% of marine and terrestrial areas by 2030, with an emphasis on sites critical for biodiversity. One mechanism to support this goal is the identification of Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs) to inform spatial planning and the development of conservation area networks. However, few case studies demonstrate how the KBA process can be implemented in high-biodiversity, low-income countries. We present a national-scale example from Mozambique, where KBAs were delineated across seven taxonomic groups, and outline a post hoc theory of change to support broader national implementation and progress towards CBD targets. We describe how the project established institutional arrangements and training to build technical capacity, highlighting the central role of the Ministry of Land and Environment. We then present the KBA identification process and results, including species Red List assessments that contributed to the identification of four marine and 25 terrestrial KBAs. With results integrated into national policy and legislation, the Mozambique KBA system demonstrates that KBA identification is feasible in lower-income countries and provides a model for broader application.

ecology↗

Global biodiversity indicators do not fully capture how land cover alters species richness and composition

Global biodiversity indicators of land-use impact are increasingly used to track international targets and to inform corporate disclosure, yet few have been tested against independent field data. Because species richness and community composition can change independently, an indicator capturing only one can miss changes in the other. Using standardized bird surveys on three continents, I show that most of seven leading indicators ranked sites within ecoregions no better than the share of natural land cover, for both richness and composition. I developed new estimates of how land cover affects richness and composition, from GBIF occurrence records open to commercial use, and tested them in the same surveys. Only the new composition estimate clearly outperformed natural-cover share for composition, and the new richness estimate predicted field richness as well as an expert-range map in two of three regions. Neither estimate could stand in for the other. Globally, assessments depended on the natural reference: cropland retained about half of the bird species of a forest reference but four-fifths of those of an open natural one. Assessing the state of nature therefore requires an explicitly justified reference, and indicators that report richness and composition as a pair and are tested against independent surveys.

ecology↗

Cold acclimation and diapause independently improve egg cold tolerance and act through distinct mechanisms in the invasive mosquito Aedes albopictus

1. Phenotypic plasticity is an important mechanism by which organisms can cope with environmental change. However, there is growing recognition that phenotypic plasticity is not a single phenomenon but instead encompasses a range of responses that vary in reversibility and are predicted to evolve under different conditions. Nevertheless, few studies have disentangled the fitness effects and mechanisms of different forms of plasticity, making it difficult to predict their respective roles in promoting population persistence in the face of climate change. 2. In our study, we assessed plasticity of egg cold tolerance in the vector mosquito Aedes albopictus, considering both irreversible plasticity caused by photoperiodically-mediated diapause and reversible plasticity caused by cold acclimation. We also analyzed metabolites and lipids to investigate the extent to which these two forms of plasticity improve cold tolerance through shared mechanisms. 3. We found that diapause and cold acclimation independently enhance cold tolerance of Ae. albopictus eggs. While the beneficial effect of diapause on cold tolerance persisted throughout our experiment, cold tolerance gained through acclimation was lost when eggs were returned to warm temperatures. 4. Cold tolerance plasticity in Ae. albopictus does not appear to be driven by the accumulation of classical cryoprotectants. Instead, reductions in citric acid cycle intermediates and free fatty acids imply that diapause induces metabolic suppression, which likely helps maintain energy balance during winter and may also improve cold tolerance by protecting against cold-induced disruption of metabolic homeostasis. Cold acclimation generally increased lipid unsaturation, which may function to preserve membrane fluidity at low temperatures. Overall, diapause and cold acclimation imparted largely nonoverlapping effects on egg metabolite and lipid profiles, indicating that these two forms of plasticity act through distinct molecular pathways. 5. In addition to identifying potential mechanisms by which an invasive vector mosquito attains cold tolerance to survive winter, our results provide evidence that irreversible and reversible plasticity are distinct phenomena capable of evolving independently during populations' responses to novel environmental conditions.

ecology↗