Elucidating Mechanisms of Tolerance to Salmonella Typhimurium Across Long-Term Infections Using the Collaborative Cross

Abstract

Understanding the molecular mechanisms underlying resistance and tolerance to pathogen infection may present the opportunity to develop novel interventions. Resistance is the absence of clinical disease with low pathogen burden, while tolerance is minimal clinical disease in the face of high pathogen burden. Salmonella is a worldwide health concern. We studied 18 strains of Collaborative Cross mice that survive acute Salmonella Typhimurium (STm) infections. We infected these strains orally and monitored them for three weeks post-infection. Five strains cleared STm by the end of the experiment (resistant), while 6 strains maintained a bacterial load and survived to the end of the experiment (tolerant). The remaining 7 strains survived longer than 7 days but succumbed to infection before the end of the study period and were called "delayed susceptible" to differentiate them from strains that do not survive to day 7 (susceptible). Tolerant strains were colonized in Peyers patches, mesenteric lymph node, spleen and liver, while resistant strains had significantly reduced bacterial colonization. Tolerant strains had lower pre-infection core body temperatures than both delayed susceptible and resistant strains and had disrupted circadian patterns of body temperature post-infection sooner than resistant strains. Tolerant strains had higher circulating total white blood cells than resistant strains, driven by increased numbers of neutrophils. Tolerant strains had more severe tissue damage and higher circulating levels of MCP-1 and IFN-{gamma}, but lower levels of ENA-78 than resistant strains. QTL analysis revealed 1 significant association and 6 suggestive associations. RNA-seq analysis identified 22 genes that are differentially regulated in tolerant versus resistant animals that overlapped with the QTLs we identified and allowed us to identify the top 5 canonical pathways. Fibrinogen genes (Fga, Fgb, and Fgg) were found across the QTL, RNA, and top canonical pathways making them the best candidate genes for differentiating tolerance and resistance. Author SummaryAn infected host can respond in multiple ways to bacterial infection including resistance and tolerance. Resistance is a decrease in pathogen load, while in tolerance mild clinical signs are present despite high pathogen load. We infected a collection of 18 strains of genetically diverse mice with Salmonella Typhimurium for up to three weeks. Five strains were resistant, 6 strains were tolerant, and the remaining 7 strains survived an intermediate amount of time ("delayed susceptible"). Tolerant strains maintained bacterial load across several organs, while resistant strains reduced bacterial load. Tolerant strains had the lowest pre-infection core body temperatures and the most rapid disruption in circadian patterns of body temperature post-infection. Tolerant strains had higher circulating neutrophils, higher circulating levels of MCP-1 and IFN-{gamma}, but lower levels of ENA-78 than resistant strains, in addition to more severe tissue damage than resistant strains. QTL analysis revealed multiple associated regions, and gene expression analysis identified 22 genes that are differentially regulated in tolerant versus resistant animals in these regions. Fibrinogen genes (Fga, Fgb, and Fgg) were found across the QTL, RNA, and top canonical pathways making them the best candidate genes for differentiating tolerance and resistance.