Origins and timing of emerging lesions in advanced renal cell carcinoma

Abstract

PurposeRenal cell carcinoma (RCC) with venous tumor thrombus (VTT) arising from the primary tumor occurs in 4-10% of cases and is associated with advanced disease. RCC with VTT and distant metastasis represents a unique clinical entity, and provides opportunities to examine the origins and relative timing of tumor lesion emergence and to identify molecular correlates with disease state. Experimental DesignWe performed genomic and evolutionary analyses on 16 RCC patients with VTT, with eight also having metastases, using multi-region exome and RNA sequencing. ResultsNo genomic alterations were specifically associated with the VTT or metastasis lesions; each tumor had multiple hallmark driver alterations, consistent with advanced disease state. We found that 21% (3/14) of clear-cell RCC cases could be assigned a previously defined "evolutionary subtype". Somatic mutation signatures were largely consistent with previously established RCC signatures, and showed low heterogeneity across regions of each tumor. Mismatch repair and homologous recombination ("BRCA-ness") deficiency signatures consistently co-occurred across most tumors, suggesting a pervasive role for intracellular DNA damage in RCC and the potential for related treatment strategies. Phylogenetic timing analysis of metastatic cases suggested that in most tumors, metastases branched from the primary tumor prior to formation of VTT and in some cases before diversification of the primary tumor. Both VTT and the earliest metastases were predicted to emerge many years prior to diagnosis. Transcriptional landscape analysis identified key differences distinguishing each lesion type from primary tumor: VTT upregulated TNF signaling and associated inflammatory pathways, whereas metastases upregulated MTOR signaling. ConclusionsOur results provide a map of how RCC tumors can evolve, with metastatic clones typically emerging early in RCC development and taking hold via MTOR signaling, and later formation of VTT via local inflammatory processes. Statement of Translational RelevanceRenal cell carcinoma (RCC) is a deadly and relatively common malignancy, which often presents as or progresses to metastatic disease. We used multi-region sequencing of RCC patients with venous tumor thrombus (VTT) and metastasis to ask how and when new lesions arise from the primary tumor, and what genomic factors contribute to their spread. Phylogenetic analysis of patients with VTT and co-presenting metastases suggested that in most cases, the VTT and metastases derive from distinct tumor clones. Moreover, metastatic clones often appear many years prior to diagnosis. We found that local TNF inflammation may contribute to VTT formation, whereas MTOR signaling is associated with metastases. Our study sheds light on the relationship of VTT and metastases, suggests therapeutic and biomarker strategies for RCC, and points to the need for early detection studies in RCC to better understand when metastases emerge and to identify at-risk patients.