A deleterious mutation-sheltering theory for the evolution of sex chromosomes and supergenes

Abstract

Many organisms have sex chromosomes with large non-recombining regions that have expanded stepwise, generating "evolutionary strata" of differentiation. The reasons for this remain poorly understood, but the principal hypotheses proposed to date are based on antagonistic selection due to differences between sexes. However, it has proved difficult to obtain empirical evidence of a role for sexually antagonistic selection in extending recombination suppression, and antagonistic selection has been shown to be unlikely to account for the evolutionary strata observed on fungal mating-type chromosomes. There may, therefore, be other mechanisms involved in the extension of non-recombining regions. We show here, by mathematical modeling and stochastic simulation, that recombination suppression on sex chromosomes and around supergenes can expand in a stepwise manner under a wide range of parameter values simply because it shelters recessive deleterious mutations, which are ubiquitous in genomes. Permanently heterozygous alleles, such as the maledetermining allele in XY systems, protect linked chromosomal inversions against the expression of their recessive mutation load, leading to the successive accumulation of inversions around these alleles without the need for antagonistic selection. Similar results were obtained with models assuming recombination-suppressing mechanisms other than chromosomal inversions, and for supergenes other than sex chromosomes, including those without XY-like asymmetry, such as fungal mating-type chromosomes. However, inversions capturing a permanently heterozygous allele were found to be less likely to spread when the mutation load was lower (e.g. under conditions of large effective population size, low mutation rates and high dominance coefficients). This may explain why sex chromosomes remain homomorphic in some organisms but are highly divergent in others. Here, we explicitly state and model a simple and testable hypothesis explaining the existence of stepwise extensions of recombination suppression on sex chromosomes, which can also be applied to mating-type chromosomes and supergenes in general.