Structurally related but genetically unrelated antibody lineages converge on an immunodominantHIV-1 Env neutralizing determinant following trimer immunization

Abstract

Understanding the molecular mechanisms by which antibodies target and neutralize the HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein (Env) is critical in guiding immunogen design and vaccine development aimed at eliciting cross-reactive neutralizing antibodies (NAbs). Here, we analyzed monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) isolated from non-human primates (NHPs) immunized with variants of a native flexibly linked (NFL) HIV-1 Env stabilized trimer derived from the tier 2 clade C 16055 strain. The antibodies displayed neutralizing activity against the autologous virus with potencies ranging from 0.005 to 3.68 ug/ml (IC50). Structural characterization using negative-stain EM and X-ray crystallography identified the variable region 2 (V2) of the 16055 NFL trimer to be the common epitope for these antibodies. The crystal structures revealed that the V2 segment adopts a {beta}-hairpin motif identical to that observed in the 16055 NFL crystal structure. These results depict how vaccine-induced antibodies derived from different clonal lineages penetrate through the glycan shield to recognize a hypervariable region within V2 (residues 184-186) that is unique to the 16055 strain. They also provide an explanation for the potent autologous neutralization of these antibodies, confirming the immunodominance of this site and revealing that multiple angles of approach are permissible for affinity/avidity that results in potent neutralizing capacity. The structural analysis reveals that the most negatively charged paratope correlated with the potency of the mAbs. The atomic level information is of interest to both define the means of autologous neutralization elicited by different tier 2-based immunogens and facilitate trimer redesign to better target more conserved regions of V2 to potentially elicit cross-neutralizing HIV-1 antibodies. Author summaryNHPs immunizations with an HIV-1 immunogen (native-like tier 2 clade C 16055 strain) elicit potent HIV-1 tier 2 autologous polyclonal neutralizing antibodies. To understand the basis of the autologous neutralization, we determined structures of antibodies isolated from the vaccinated NHPs in complex with their epitopes. Our structural analysis reveals that the V2 hypervariable region, unique to 16055, is immunodominant and targeted by antibodies from diverse lineages. Additionally, vaccine-elicited V2 NAbs use different binding angles to avoid Env N-glycan shield and the more negatively charged paratope displays potent autologous neutralizing function. In summary, detailed analysis of how vaccine-elicited monoclonal antibodies interact with the target antigen provide valuable information for the design of immunogens aimed to elicit more broadly HIV-neutralizing antibodies. The use of cocktail/prime-boost sequential regimens that include a range of sequence variation combined with the removal/shielding of unwanted immunodominant epitopes will likely be needed to reach this goal.