Ongoing production of low-fitness hybrids limits range overlap between divergent cryptic species

Abstract

Contact zones between recently-diverged taxa provide opportunities to examine the causes of reproductive isolation and to examine the processes that determine whether two species can coexist over a broad region. The Pacific Wren (Troglodytes pacificus) and the Winter Wren (Troglodytes hiemalis) are two morphologically similar songbird species that started diverging about 4 million years ago, older than most sister species pairs. The ranges of these species come into narrow contact in western Canada, where the two species remain distinct in sympatry. To assess evidence for differentiation, hybridization, and introgression in this system, we examined variation in over 250,000 single nucleotide polymorphism markers distributed across the genomes of the two species. The two species formed highly divergent genetic clusters, consistent with long-term differentiation. In a set of 75 individuals from allopatry and sympatry, two first-generation hybrids (i.e., F1s) were detected, indicating only moderate levels of assortative mating between these taxa. We found no recent backcrosses or F2s or other evidence of recent breeding success of F1 hybrids, indicating very low or zero fitness of F1 hybrids. Examination of genomic variation shows evidence for only a single backcrossing event in the distant past. The sizeable rate of hybridization combined with very low fitness of F1 hybrids is expected to result in a population sink in the contact zone, largely explaining the narrow overlap of the two species. If such dynamics are common in nature, they could explain the narrow range overlap often observed between pairs of closely related species. Additionally, we present evidence for a rare duplication of a large chromosomal segment from an autosome to the W chromosome, the female-specific sex chromosome in birds.