High levels of Dorsal transcription factor downregulate, not promote, snail expression by regulating enhancer action

Abstract

In Drosophila embryos, genes expressed along the dorsal-ventral axis are responsive to concentration of the Dorsal (Dl) transcription factor, which varies in space; however, levels of this morphogen also build over time. Since expression of high-threshold Dl target genes such as snail (sna) is supported before Dl levels peak, it is unclear what role increasing levels have if any. Here we investigated action of two enhancers that control sna expression in embryos, demonstrating using genome editing that Dl binding sites within one enhancer located promoter proximally, sna.prox, can limit the ability of the other distally-located enhancer, sna.dis, to increase sna levels. In addition, MS2-MCP live imaging was used to study sna transcription rate in wildtype, dl heterozygote, and a background in which a photo-sensitive degron is fused to Dl (dl-BLID). The results demonstrate that, when Dl levels are high, Dl acts through sna.prox to limit the activity of sna.dis and thereby influence sna transcription rate. In contrast, when Dl levels are kept low using dl-BLID, sna.prox positively influences sna transcription rate. Collectively, our data support the view that Dls effect on gene expression changes over time, switching from promoting sna expression at low concentration to dampening sna expression at high concentration by regulating enhancer interactions. We propose this differential action of the Dl morphogen is likely supported by occupancy of this factor first to high and then low affinity binding sites over time as Dl levels rise to coordinate action of these two co-acting enhancers. Significance statementA gradient of the maternal transcription factor Dorsal is important for establishing spatial expression of target genes along the dorsal-ventral axis of Drosophila embryos. Dorsal levels are also dynamic as nuclear concentration builds in time. Surprisingly, expression of high-threshold target genes such as snail is supported before levels peak, raising the question why levels continue to build. Our data support the view that peak Dorsal levels act to preferentially support activity of one enhancer over another to effectively decrease snail expression. In addition, while the morphogen Dorsal acts early to support gene expression, later it effectively acts as a damper to limit gene expression. Our results suggest other morphogens also have effects on gene expression that change over time.