Custom-molded headcases have limited efficacy in reducing head motion for fMRI

Abstract

Effectively minimizing head motion continues to be a challenge for the collection of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data. The use of individual-specific custom molded headcases is a promising solution to this issue, but there has been limited work to date. In the present work, we examine the efficacy of headcases in a larger group of participants engaged in naturalistic scanning paradigms including: long movie-watching scans ([~]20-45min) and a recall task that involved talking aloud inside the MRI. Unlike previous work, we find that headcases do not reliably reduce motion during movie viewing compared to alternative methods such as foam pillows or foam pillows plus medical tape. Surprisingly, we also find that motion is worse when participants talk aloud while wearing headcases. These differences appear to be driven by large, brief rotations of the head as well as translations in the z-plane as participants speak. Smaller, constant head movements appear equivalent with or without headcases. The largest reductions in head motion are observable when participants were situated with both foam pillows and medical tape. Altogether, this work suggests that in a healthy adult population, custom-molded headcases may provide limited efficacy in reducing head motion beyond existing tools available to researchers. We hope this work can help improve the quality of custom headcases, motivate the investigation of additional solutions, and provide additional information about head motion in naturalistic contexts.