Transfer from number to size reveals abstract coding of magnitude in honeybees

Abstract

Number discrimination has been documented in honeybees. It is not known, however, whether it reflects, as in vertebrates, the operating of an underlying general magnitude system that estimates quantities irrespective of dimensions (e.g., number, space, time) and format (discrete, continuous). We investigated whether bees spontaneously transfer discrete discrimination of number to continuous discrimination of size. Bees were trained to discriminate between different numerical comparisons having either a 0.5 (2 vs. 4 and 4 vs. 8) or 0.67 ratio (2 vs. 3 and 4 vs. 6). Half of the subjects learnt to choose the smaller quantity and the other half the larger quantity. Bees were then tested for spontaneous choice (in the absence of reward) using comparisons with identical numbers but different sizes. Irrespective of the ratio of the stimuli, bees trained to select the smaller numerical quantity chose the congruent smaller size; bees trained to choose the larger numerical quantity chose the congruent larger size. This finding provides the first evidence for a cross-dimensional transfer between discrete (numerical) and continuous (spatial) dimensions in an invertebrate species and supports the hypothesis of a cognitive universality of a coding for general magnitude.