The direction of local adaptation on pathogen exploitation rates reverses with environmental context
Host heterogeneity and spatial population structure each influence parasite evolution but may also interact because space structures contacts between host types. Here, we experimentally evolve granulosis virus in microcosms of its Plodia interpunctella (Indian meal moth) host that differ in both spatial structure and host genetic diversity. We control spatial structure by manipulating the viscosity of the food that the larvae live within and host genetic diversity by adding larvae from either a single or two inbred lines to opposite ends of the microcosm. We preserve spatial structure across passages and assay virus from different positions within the microcosm on both host genotypes. We find that the lower contact rates between host genotypes resulting from spatial structure can lead to the evolution of locally specialized virus, even when the host population is genetically diverse overall. We also find that spatial structure changes how viruses specialize: viruses evolved in well-mixed environments had lower exploitation of familiar hosts, while those in spatially structured environments exhibited higher exploitation of familiar hosts. These results demonstrate that spatial structure and host heterogeneity interact to shape pathogen specialization and that the evolutionary consequences of host diversity depends on the population structure.