Land-use change undermines the stability of avian functional diversity
Land-use change causes widespread shifts in the composition and functional diversity (FD) of species assemblages, yet the impacts on ecosystem resilience remain uncertain. Stability of ecosystem functioning may increase after land-use change because the most sensitive species are removed, leaving more resilient survivors (Balmford, 1996; Clavel et al., 2010; McKinney & Lockwood, 1999). Alternatively, ecosystems may be destabilized if land-use change reduces functional redundancy, accentuating the ecological impacts of further species loss (Fonseca & Ganade, 2001; McCann, 2000). Current evidence is inconclusive, partly because trait data have not been available to quantify functional stability at sufficient scale. Here, we use morphological measurements of 3696 bird species to estimate shifts in functional redundancy following recent anthropogenic land-use change at 1281 sites worldwide, and then assess the sensitivity of these altered assemblages to future species loss. We find that the proportion of disturbance-tolerant species increases after land-use change, but that this does not increase stability. Instead, we show that functional redundancy is reduced and that further species loss will destabilize ecosystem function because relatively few additional extinctions lead to accelerated losses of FD, particularly in trophic groups delivering important ecological services such as seed dispersal and insect predation. Our analyses reveal that land-use change may have major undetected impacts on the stability of key ecological functions, hindering the capacity of natural ecosystems to absorb further declines in functionality caused by ongoing perturbations.