Phase separating RNA binding proteins form heterogeneous distributions of clusters in subsaturated solutions
Macromolecular phase separation is thought to be one of the processes that drives the formation of membraneless biomolecular condensates in cells. The dynamics of phase separation, especially at low endogenous concentrations found in cells, are thought to follow the tenets of classical nucleation theory describing a sharp transition between a dense phase and a dilute phase characterized by dispersed monomers. Here, we used in vitro biophysical studies to study subsaturated solutions of phase separating RNA binding proteins with intrinsically disordered prion like domains (PLDs) and RNA binding domains (RBDs). Surprisingly, we find that subsaturated solutions are characterized by heterogeneous distributions of clusters comprising tens to hundreds of molecules. These clusters also include low abundance mesoscale species that are several hundreds of nanometers in diameter. Our results show that cluster formation in subsaturated solutions and phase separation in supersaturated solutions are strongly coupled via sequence-encoded interactions. Interestingly, however, cluster formation and phase separation can be decoupled from one another using solutes that impact the solubilities of phase separating proteins. They can also be decoupled by specific types of mutations. Overall, our findings implicate the presence of distinct, sequence-specific energy scales that contribute to the overall phase behaviors of RNA binding proteins. We discuss our findings in the context of theories of associative polymers. Significance StatementMembraneless biomolecular condensates are molecular communities with distinct compositional preferences and functions. Considerable attention has focused on phase separation as the process that gives rise to condensates. Here, we show that subsaturated solutions of RNA binding proteins form heterogeneous distributions of clusters in subsaturated solutions. The formation of clusters in subsaturated solutions and condensates in supersaturated solution are coupled through sequence-specific interactions. Given the low endogenous concentrations of phase separating proteins, our findings suggest that clusters in subsaturated conditions might be of functional relevance in cells.