Mature tumoroids recapitulate clinically relevant drug response through extended 3D culture in PDAC
BackgroundDrug responses in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) vary sharply across in vitro culture formats, but most 2D-3D comparisons conflate microenvironmental cues with time-dependent cellular adaptation. As a result, conventional assays frequently overestimate drug efficacy and poorly reflect clinical pharmacology. Main findingsWe profiled MiaPaCa-2, PANC-1, and CFPAC-1 grown in an extracellular-matrix (ECM) hydrogel for 1-12 days, defining extended 3D cultures ([≥]10 days) as mature tumoroids, and quantified 72 h drug responses to a multi-class oncology panel using growth-rate (GR) metrics to normalize for proliferation across formats and durations. Prolonged 3D pre-culture induced broad tolerance, with typical 10-100x reductions in sensitivity to standards of care (5-fluorouracil, SN38, oxaliplatin, gemcitabine, paclitaxel), following a reproducible susceptibility hierarchy (MiaPaCa-2 > PANC-1 > CFPAC-1) after GR correction. In mature tumoroids, GR values closely approximated clinically observed plasma exposures (e.g., within <4x for 5-FU and <0.5x for gemcitabine), whereas 2D and short-term organoid assays markedly underestimated resistance, often by >100x, thereby overstating drug activity. Notably, CFPAC-1 exhibited increased sensitivity to SN38 and trametinib under mature-organoid conditions, demonstrating that microenvironmental conditioning can invert responses for selected mechanisms. Transcriptomic profiling revealed coordinated up-regulation of multiple ABC transporters with extended 3D residence, tracking resistance phenotypes across lines and implicating transporter-linked tolerance programs. SignificanceTogether, these data identify time-in-3D and the emergence of mature tumoroids as dominant, previously under-controlled determinants of PDAC pharmacology that both induce tolerance and unmask context-dependent vulnerabilities. We propose incorporating both short-term and mature-tumoroid screening arms into preclinical workflows, reporting pre-culture duration alongside GR-normalized effect sizes, and leveraging transporter-informed biomarkers to guide regimen prioritization and sequencing. This framework enhances physiological relevance, reproducibility, and translational fidelity in PDAC drug discovery.