Search bioRxiv⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Sharbrough, J.

Publications and source records attributed to Sharbrough, J..

15 recordsLinked to original sources

Whole-genome sequence of Potamopyrgus antipodarum: a model system for the maintenance of sexual reproduction reveals a recent whole-genome duplication

Key unanswered questions in biology center on the causes, consequences, and maintenance of sexual reproduction ("sex"). Genome-driven processes are central to the evolutionary and genetic mechanisms inherent to sex, making genomic resources a fundamental part of answering these questions. We present the first genome assembly for a species that is uniquely well-suited for the study of (a)sex in nature, Potamopyrgus antipodarum. This New Zealand snail is unusual in featuring multiple separate transitions from obligately sexual to obligately asexual reproduction, leading to the coexistence of phenotypically similar sexual and asexual forms, a feature that is required to directly study the maintenance of sex. These separately derived asexual lineages constitute separate evolutionary experiments, providing a powerful means of characterizing how the absence of sex affects genome evolution. Our genome assembly provides critical steps towards understanding causes and consequences of sex in this system and important resources for the rapidly growing P. antipodarum and molluscan genomics research community. In characterizing this genome, we uncovered unexpected evidence for a recent whole-genome duplication (WGD) in P. antipodarum. This discovery sets the stage for using P. antipodarum to evaluate processes of rediploidization following WGD and assess whether WGD might drive transitions to asexuality.

genomics↗

Little Evidence for Homoeologous Gene Conversion and Homoeologous Exchange Events in Gossypium Allopolyploids

A complicating factor in analyzing allopolyploid genomes is the possibility of physical interactions between homoeologous chromosomes during meiosis, resulting in either crossover (homoeologous exchanges) or non-crossover products (homoeologous gene conversion). This latter process was first described in cotton by comparing SNP patterns in sequences from two diploid progenitors with those from the allopolyploid subgenomes. These analyses, however, did not explicitly account for autapomorphic SNPs that may lead to similar patterns as homoeologous gene conversion, creating uncertainties about the reality of the inferred gene conversion events. Here, we use an expanded phylogenetic sampling of high-quality genome assemblies from seven allopolyploid Gossypium species (all derived from the same polyploidy event), four diploid species (two closely related to each subgenome), and a diploid outgroup to derive a robust method for identifying potential genomic regions of gene conversion and homoeologous exchange. Using this new method, we find little evidence for homoeologous gene conversion in allopolyploid cottons and that only two of the forty best-supported events are shared by more than one species. We do, however, reveal a single, shared homoeologous exchange event at one end of chromosome 1, which occurred shortly after allopolyploidization but prior to divergence of the descendant species. Overall, our analyses demonstrate that homoeologous gene conversion and homoeologous exchanges are uncommon in Gossypium, affecting between zero and 24 genes per subgenome (0.0 - 0.065%) across the seven species. More generally, we highlight the potential problems of using simple four-taxon tests to investigate patterns of homoeologous gene conversion in established allopolyploids. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENTAllopolyploidy is a prominent process in plant diversification, involving the union of two divergent genomes in a single nucleus via interspecific hybridization and genome doubling. The merger of genomes sets in motion a variety of inter-genomic and epigenomic interactions that are thought to lead to the origin of new phenotypes. Among these is recombinational exchange between duplicated chromosomes, which can involve sequence lengths ranging from several bases to entire chromosome arms, and which can be either reciprocal or unidirectional in their effects. Here we present a new analytical framework for detecting these inter-genomic recombinational processes in allopolyploids, and demonstrate that they have been rare in a group of allopolyploid species in the cotton genus.

evolutionary biology↗

Genome evolution and introgression in the New Zealand mud snails Potamopyrgus estuarinus and Potamopyrgus kaitunuparaoa

We have sequenced, assembled, and analyzed the nuclear and mitochondrial genomes and transcriptomes of Potamopyrgus estuarinus and Potamopyrgus kaitunuparaoa, two prosobranch snail species native to New Zealand that together span the continuum from estuary to freshwater. These two species are the closest known relatives of the freshwater species P. antipodarum--a model for studying the evolution of sex, host-parasite coevolution, and biological invasiveness--and thus provide key evolutionary context for understanding its unusual biology. The P. estuarinus and P. kaitunuparaoa genomes are very similar in size and overall gene content. Comparative analyses of genome content indicate that these two species harbor a near-identical set of genes involved in meiosis and sperm functions, including seven genes with meiosis-specific functions. These results are consistent with obligate sexual reproduction in these two species and provide a framework for future analyses of P. antipodarum--a species comprising both obligately sexual and obligately asexual lineages, each separately derived from a sexual ancestor. Genome-wide multigene phylogenetic analyses indicate that P. kaitunuparaoa is likely the closest relative to P. antipodarum. We nevertheless show that there has been considerable introgression between P. estuarinus and P. kaitunuparaoa. That introgression does not extend to the mitochondrial genome, which appears to serve as a barrier to hybridization between P. estuarinus and P. kaitunuparaoa. Nuclear-encoded genes whose products function in joint mitochondrial-nuclear enzyme complexes exhibit similar patterns of non-introgression, indicating that incompatibilities between the mitochondrial and the nuclear genome may have prevented more extensive gene flow between these two species. Significance StatementNo whole-nuclear genome sequences are currently available for snails of the genus Potamopyrgus, best known for Potamopyrgus antipodarum, an invasive species of rivers and lakes worldwide, and a famous model for the study of the evolution of sex. We have sequenced and analyzed the genome of sexual P. estuarinus and P. kaitunuparaoa, the closest known relatives of P. antipodarum. We show that 1) the genomes are very similar in gene content and size, 2) P. kaitunuparaoa is the closest relative to P. antipodarum, 3) significant introgression has occurred between P. estuarinus and P. kaitunuparaoa; these genomes set the stage for powerful direct analyses of the genomic features, e.g., sex to asexual transitions and invasive success, that make P. antipodarum unique.

evolutionary biology↗

Genome-wide patterns of homoeologous gene flow in allotetraploid coffee

PremiseAllopolyploidy - a hybridization-induced whole-genome duplication event - has been a major driver of plant diversification. The extent to which chromosomes pair with their proper homolog vs. with their homoeolog in allopolyploids varies across taxa, and methods to detect homoeologous gene flow (HGF) are needed to understand how HGF has shaped polyploid lineages. MethodsThe ABBA-BABA test represents a classic method for detecting introgression between closely related species, but here we developed a modified use of the ABBA-BABA test to characterize the extent and direction of HGF in allotetraploid Coffea arabica. ResultsWe found that HGF is abundant in the C. arabica genome, with both subgenomes serving as donors and recipients of variation. We also found that HGF is highly maternally biased in plastid-targeted - but not mitochondrial-targeted - genes, as would be expected if plastid-nuclear incompatibilities exist between the two parent species. DiscussionTogether our analyses provide a simple framework for detecting HGF and new evidence consistent with selection favoring overwriting of paternally derived alleles by maternally derived alleles to ameliorate plastid-nuclear incompatibilities. Natural selection therefore appears to shape the direction and intensity of HGF in allopolyploid coffee, indicating that cytoplasmic inheritance has long-term consequences for polyploid lineages.

evolutionary biology↗

Single-molecule sequencing of animal mitochondrial genomes reveals chloroplast-like architecture and repeat-mediated recombination

Recent advances in long-read sequencing technology have allowed for single-molecule sequencing of entire mitochondrial genomes, opening the door for direct investigation of mitochondrial genome architecture and landscapes of recombination. We used PacBio sequencing to re-assemble mitochondrial genomes from two species of New Zealand freshwater snails, Potamopyrgus antipodarum and Potamopyrgus estuarinus. These assemblies revealed a [~]1.7 kb structure within the mitochondrial genomes of both species that was previously undetected by assembly of short sequencing reads and likely corresponding to a large non-coding region commonly present in mitochondrial genomes. The overall architecture of these Potamopyrgus mitochondrial genomes is reminiscent of the chloroplast genomes of land plants, harboring a large single-copy region (LSC) and a small single-copy region (SSC) separated by a pair of inverted repeats (IRa and IRb). Individual sequencing reads that spanned across the Potamopyrgus IRa-SSC-IRb structure revealed the occurrence of "flip-flop" recombination, apparently mediated by the IRs. We also detected evidence for two distinct IR haplotypes and recombination between them in wild-caught P. estuarinus, as well as extensive inter-molecular recombination between SNPs in the LSC region. Together, these observations suggest that mitochondrial inheritance is not strictly maternal in these snails. The chloroplast-like architecture and repeat-mediated mitochondrial recombination we describe here raise fundamental questions regarding the origins and commonness of such architecture, whether and how recombination mediates mitochondrial genome evolution, and the role of genome architecture in driving cytoplasmic genome biology and the maintenance of cytoplasmic genomes.

evolutionary biology↗

Organellar transcripts dominate the cellular mRNA pool across plants of varying ploidy levels

Mitochondrial and plastid functions depend on coordinated expression of proteins encoded by genomic compartments that have radical differences in copy number of organellar and nuclear genomes. In polyploids, doubling of the nuclear genome may add challenges to maintaining balanced expression of proteins involved in cytonuclear interactions. Here, we use ribo-depleted RNA-seq to analyze transcript abundance for nuclear and organellar genomes in leaf tissue from four different polyploid angiosperms and their close diploid relatives. We find that, even though plastid genomes contain <1% of the number of genes in the nuclear genome, they generate the majority (69.9-82.3%) of mRNA transcripts in the cell. Mitochondrial genes are responsible for a much smaller percentage (1.3-3.7%) of the leaf mRNA pool but still produce much higher transcript abundances per gene compared to nuclear genome. Nuclear genes encoding proteins that functionally interact with mitochondrial or plastid gene products exhibit mRNA expression levels that are consistently more than ten-fold lower than their organellar counterparts, indicating an extreme cytonuclear imbalance at the RNA level despite the predominance of equimolar interactions at the protein level. Nevertheless, interacting nuclear and organellar genes show strongly correlated transcript abundances across functional categories, suggesting that the observed mRNA stoichiometric imbalance does not preclude coordination of cytonuclear expression. Finally, we show that nuclear genome doubling does not alter the cytonuclear expression ratios observed in diploid relatives in consistent or systematic ways, indicating that successful polyploid plants are able to compensate for cytonuclear perturbations associated with nuclear genome doubling.

plant biology↗

Variation in cytonuclear expression accommodation among allopolyploid plants

Cytonuclear coevolution is a common feature among plants, which coordinates gene expression and protein products between the nucleus and organelles. Consequently, lineage-specific differences may result in incompatibilities between the nucleus and cytoplasm in hybrid taxa. Allopolyploidy is also a common phenomenon in plant evolution. The hybrid nature of allopolyploids may result in cytonuclear incompatibilities, but the massive nuclear redundancy created during polyploidy affords additional avenues for resolving cytonuclear conflict (i.e., cytonuclear accommodation). Here we evaluate expression changes in organelle-targeted nuclear genes for six allopolyploid lineages that represent four genera (i.e., Arabidopsis, Arachis, Chenopodium, and Gossypium) and encompass a range in polyploid ages. Because incompatibilities between the nucleus and cytoplasm could potentially result in biases toward the maternal homoeolog and/or maternal expression level, we evaluate patterns of homoeolog usage, expression bias, and expression level dominance in cytonuclear genes relative to the background of non-cytonuclear expression changes and to the diploid parents. Although we find subsets of cytonuclear genes in most lineages that match our expectations of maternal preference, these observations are not consistent among either allopolyploids or categories of organelle-targeted genes. Our results indicate that cytonuclear expression accommodation may be a subtle and/or variable phenomenon that does not capture the full range of mechanisms by which allopolyploid plants resolve nuclear-cytoplasmic incompatibilities.

evolutionary biology↗

Dual domestication, diversity, and differential introgression in Old World cotton diploids

Domestication in the cotton genus is remarkable in that it has occurred independently four different times at two different ploidy levels. Relatively little is known about genome evolution and domestication in the cultivated diploid species Gossypium herbaceum and G. arboreum, because of the absence of wild representatives for the latter species, their ancient domestication, and their joint history of human-mediated dispersal and interspecific gene flow. Using in-depth resequencing of a broad sampling from both species, we confirm their independent domestication, as opposed to a progenitor-derivative relationship, showing that diversity (mean {pi} = 2.3x10-3) within species is similar, and that divergence between species is modest (weighted FST=0.4430). Individual accessions were homozygous for ancestral SNPs at over half of variable sites, while fixed, derived sites were at modest frequencies. Notably, two chromosomes with a paucity of fixed, derived sites (i.e., chromosomes 7 and 10) were also strongly implicated in introgression analyses. Collectively, these data demonstrate variable permeability to introgression among chromosomes, which we propose is due to divergent selection under domestication and/or the phenomenon of F2 breakdown in interspecific crosses. Our analyses provide insight into the evolutionary forces influencing diversity and divergence in the diploid cultivated species, and establish a foundation for understanding the contribution of introgression and/or strong parallel selection to the extensive morphological similarities shared between species. Significance statementThe cotton genus (Gossypium) contains four different species that were independently domesticated at least 4,000 years ago. Relatively little is understood about diversity and evolution in the two diploid African-Asian sister-species G. herbaceum and G. arboreum, despite their historical importance in the region and contemporary cultivation, largely in the Indian subcontinent. Here we address questions regarding the relationship between the two species, their contemporary levels of diversity, and their patterns of interspecific gene flow accompanying their several millennia history of human-mediated dispersal and contact. We validate independent domestication of the two species and document the genomic distribution of interspecific genetic exchange.

evolutionary biology↗

Global patterns of subgenome evolution in organelle-targeted genes of sixallotetraploid angiosperms

Whole-genome duplications (WGDs), in which the number of nuclear genome copies is elevated as a result of autopolyploidy or allopolyploidy, are a prominent process of diversification in eukaryotes. The genetic and evolutionary forces that WGD imposes upon cytoplasmic genomes are not well understood, despite the central role that cytonuclear interactions play in eukaryotic function and fitness. Cellular respiration and photosynthesis depend upon successful interaction between the 3000+ nuclear-encoded proteins destined for the mitochondria or plastids and the gene products of cytoplasmic genomes in multi-subunit complexes such as OXPHOS, organellar ribosomes, Photosystems I and II, and Rubisco. Allopolyploids are thus faced with the critical task of coordinating interactions between nuclear and cytoplasmic genes that were inherited from different species. Because cytoplasmic genomes share a more recent history of common descent with the maternal nuclear subgenome than the paternal subgenome, evolutionary "mismatches" between the paternal subgenome and the cytoplasmic genomes in allopolyploids might lead to accelerated rates of evolution in the paternal homoeologs of allopolyploids, either through relaxed purifying selection or strong directional selection to rectify these mismatches. We tested this hypothesis in maternal vs. paternal copies of organelle-targeted genes in six allotetraploids: Brachypodium hybridum, Chenopodium quinoa, Coffea arabica, Gossypium hirsutum, Nicotiana tabacum, and Triticum dicoccoides. We report evidence that allopolyploid subgenomes exhibit unequal rates of protein-sequence evolution, but we did not observe global effects of cytonuclear incompatibilities on paternal homoeologs of organelle-targeted genes. Analyses of gene content revealed mixed evidence for whether organelle-targeted genes re-diploidize more rapidly than non-organelle-targeted genes. Together, these global analyses provide insights into the complex evolutionary dynamics of allopolyploids, showing that allopolyploid subgenomes have separate evolutionary trajectories despite sharing the same nucleus, generation time, and ecological context. AUTHOR SUMMARY Whole genome duplication, in which the size and content of the nuclear genome is instantly doubled, represents one of the most profound forms of mutational change. The consequences of duplication events are equally monumental, especially considering that almost all eukaryotes have undergone whole genome duplications during their evolutionary history. While myriad genetic, cellular, organismal, and ecological effects of whole genome duplications have been extensively documented, relatively little attention has been paid to the diminutive but essential "other" genomes present inside the cell, those of chloroplasts and mitochondria. In this study, we compared the evolutionary patterns of >340,000 genes from 23 species to test whether whole genome duplications are associated with genetic mismatches between the nuclear, mitochondrial, and chloroplast genomes. We discovered tremendous differences between duplicated copies of nuclear genomes; however, mitochondria-nuclear and chloroplast-nuclear mismatches do not appear to be common following whole genome duplications. Together these genomic data represent the most extensive analysis yet performed on how polyploids maintain the delicate and finely tuned balance between the nuclear, mitochondrial, and chloroplast genomes.

evolutionary biology↗

Nuclear-cytoplasmic balance: whole genome duplications induce elevated organellar genome copy number

The plant genome is partitioned across three distinct subcellular compartments: the nucleus, mitochondria, and plastids. Successful coordination of gene expression among these organellar genomes and the nuclear genome is critical for plant function and fitness. Whole genome duplication events (WGDs) in the nucleus have played a major role in the diversification of land plants and are expected to perturb the relative copy number (stoichiometry) of nuclear, mitochondrial, and plastid genomes. Thus, elucidating the mechanisms whereby plant cells respond to the cytonuclear stoichiometric imbalance that follow WGDs represents an important yet underexplored question in understanding the evolutionary consequences of genome doubling. We used droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) to investigate the relationship between nuclear and organellar genome copy numbers in allopolyploids and their diploid progenitors in both wheat and Arabidopsis. Polyploids exhibit elevated organellar genome copy numbers per cell, largely preserving the cytonuclear stoichiometry observed in diploids despite the change in nuclear genome copy number. To investigate the timescale over which cytonuclear stoichiometry may respond to WGD, we also estimated organellar genome copy number in Arabidopsis synthetic autopolyploids and in a haploid-induced diploid line. We observed corresponding changes in organellar genome copy number in these laboratory-generated lines, indicating that at least some of the cellular response to cytonuclear stoichiometric imbalance is immediate following WGD. We conclude that increases in organellar genome copy numbers represent a common response to polyploidization, suggesting that maintenance of cytonuclear stoichiometry is an important component in establishing polyploid lineages. Significance StatementWhole genome duplications (WGD) have the potential to alter the stoichiometric balance between nuclear and organellar genomes. We used two separate diploid-polyploid complexes to show that plant cells with WGD exhibit elevated mitochondrial and plastid genome copy numbers, both immediately in lab-generated lines and in natural polyploids.

evolutionary biology↗

pSONIC: Ploidy-aware Syntenic Orthologous Networks Identified via Collinearity

With the rapid rise in availability of high-quality genomes for closely related species, methods for orthology inference that incorporate synteny are increasingly useful. Polyploidy perturbs the 1:1 expected frequencies of orthologs between two species, complicating the identification of orthologs. Here we present a method of ortholog inference, Ploidy-aware Syntenic Orthologous Networks Identified via Collinearity (pSONIC). We demonstrate the utility of pSONIC using four species in the cotton tribe (Gossypieae), including one allopolyploid, and place between 75-90% of genes from each species into nearly 32,000 orthologous groups, 97% of which consist of at most singletons or tandemly duplicated genes -- 58.8% more than comparable methods that do not incorporate synteny. We show that 99% of singleton gene groups follow the expected tree topology, and that our ploidy-aware algorithm recovers 97.5% identical groups when compared to splitting the allopolyploid into its two respective subgenomes, treating each as separate "species".

genomics↗

CyMIRA: The Cytonuclear Molecular Interactions Reference for Arabidopsis

The function and evolution of eukaryotic cells depends upon direct molecular interactions between gene products encoded in nuclear and cytoplasmic genomes. Understanding how these cytonuclear interactions drive molecular evolution and generate genetic incompatibilities between isolated populations and species is of central importance to eukaryotic biology. Plants are an outstanding system to investigate such effects because of their two different genomic compartments present in the cytoplasm (mitochondria and plastids) and the extensive resources detailing subcellular targeting of nuclear-encoded proteins. However, the field lacks a consistent classification scheme for mitochondrial- and plastid-targeted proteins based on their molecular interactions with cytoplasmic genomes and gene products, which hinders efforts to standardize and compare results across studies. Here, we take advantage of detailed knowledge about the model angiosperm Arabidopsis thaliana to provide a curated database of plant cytonuclear interactions at the molecular level. CyMIRA (Cytonuclear Molecular Interactions Reference for Arabidopsis) is available at http://cymira.colostate.edu/ and https://github.com/dbsloan/cymira and will serve as a resource to aid researchers in partitioning evolutionary genomic data into functional gene classes based on organelle targeting and direct molecular interaction with cytoplasmic genomes and gene products. It includes 11 categories (and 27 subcategories) of different cytonuclear complexes and types of molecular interactions, and it reports residue-level information for cytonuclear contact sites. We hope that this framework will make it easier to standardize, interpret and compare studies testing the functional and evolutionary consequences of cytonuclear interactions.

genomics↗

An improved mitochondrial reference genome for Arabidopsis thaliana Col-0

Arabidopsis thaliana remains the foremost model system for plant genetics and genomics, and researchers rely on the accuracy of its genomic resources. The first completely sequenced angiosperm mitochondrial genome was obtained from A. thaliana C24 (Unseld et al., 1997), and more recent efforts have produced additional A. thaliana reference genomes, including one for Col-0, the most widely used ecotype (Davila et al., 2011). These studies were based on older DNA sequencing methods, making them subject to errors associated with lower levels of sequencing coverage or the extremely short read lengths produced by early-generation Illumina technologies. Indeed, although the more recently published A. thaliana mitochondrial reference genome sequences made substantial progress in improving upon earlier versions, they still have high error rates. By comparing publicly available Illumina sequence data to the A. thaliana Col-0 reference genome, we found that it contains a sequence error every 2.4 kb on average, including 57 SNPs, 96 indels (up to 901 bp in size), and a large repeat-mediated rearrangement. Most of these errors appear to have been carried over from the original A. thaliana mitochondrial genome sequence by reference-based assembly approaches, which has misled subsequent studies of plant mitochondrial mutation and molecular evolution by giving the false impression that the errors are naturally occurring variants present in multiple ecotypes. Building on the progress made by previous researchers, we provide a corrected reference sequence that we hope will serve as a useful community resource for future investigations in the field of plant mitochondrial genetics.

genomics↗

Variation in physiological function across source populations of a New Zealand freshwater snail

Mitochondrial function is critical for energy homeostasis and should shape how genetic variation in metabolism is transmitted through levels of biological organization to generate stability in organismal performance. Mitochondrial function is encoded by genes in two distinct and separately inherited genomes - the mitochondrial genome and the nuclear genome - and selection is expected to maintain functional mito-nuclear interactions. Nevertheless, high levels of polymorphism in genes involved in these mito-nuclear interactions and variation for mitochondrial function are nevertheless frequently observed, demanding an explanation for how and why variability in such a fundamental trait is maintained. Potamopyrgus antipodarum is a New Zealand freshwater snail with coexisting sexual and asexual individuals and, accordingly, contrasting systems of separate vs. co-inheritance of nuclear and mitochondrial genomes. As such, this snail provides a powerful means to dissect the evolutionary and functional consequences of mito-nuclear variation. The lakes inhabited by P. antipodarum span wide environmental gradients, with substantial across-lake genetic structure and mito-nuclear discordance. This situation allows us to use comparisons across reproductive modes and lakes to partition variation in cellular respiration across genetic and environmental axes. Here, we integrated cellular, physiological, and behavioral approaches to quantify variation in mitochondrial function across a diverse set of wild P. antipodarum lineages. We found extensive across-lake variation in organismal oxygen consumption, mitochondrial membrane potential, and behavioral response to heat stress, but few global effects of reproductive mode or sex. Taken together, our data set the stage for applying this important model system for sexual reproduction and polyploidy to dissecting the complex relationships between mito-nuclear variation, performance, plasticity, and fitness in natural populations.

evolutionary biology↗

Genetic variation for mitochondrial function in the New Zealand freshwater snail Potamopyrgus antipodarum

The proteins responsible for mitochondrial function are encoded by two different genomes with distinct inheritance regimes, rendering rigorous inference of genotype-phenotype connections intractable for all but a few model systems. Asexual organisms provide a powerful means for addressing these challenges because offspring produced without recombination inherit both nuclear and mitochondrial genomes from a single parent. As such, these offspring inherit mitonuclear genotypes that are identical to the mitonuclear genotypes of their parents and siblings and different from those of other asexual lineages. Here, we compared mitochondrial function across distinct asexual lineages of Potamopyrgus antipodarum, a New Zealand freshwater snail model for understanding the evolutionary consequences of asexuality. Our analyses revealed substantial phenotypic variation across asexual lineages at three levels of biological organization: mitogenomic, organellar, and organismal. These data demonstrate that different asexual lineages have different mitochondrial function phenotypes and that there exists heritable variation (that is, the raw material for evolution) for mitochondrial function in P. antipodarum. The discovery of this variation combined with the methods developed here sets the stage to use P. antipodarum to study central evolutionary questions involving mitochondrial function, including whether mitochondrial mutation accumulation influences the maintenance of sexual reproduction in natural populations.

evolutionary biology↗