Search bioRxiv⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Seymour, B.

Publications and source records attributed to Seymour, B..

16 recordsLinked to original sources

Entropy regularised reinforcement learning reconciles aversive and action prediction errors in the tail of the striatum

AO_SCPLOWBSTRACTC_SCPLOWDopamine activity in the tail of the striatum (TS) presents a novel challenge for reinforcement-learning theories of dopamine. Some studies suggest that TS-projecting dopamine signals encode aversive or threat prediction errors, whereas others argue that they encode action prediction errors involved in soft-habit formation. Here, we show that these accounts need not be mutually exclusive. We instantiate an entropy-regularised reinforcement-learning model in which TS-projecting dopamine neurons update both aversive values and the default policy. In this model, threat belief gates aversive value initialisations, producing TS-like activity during retreat from potentially threatening novel objects, while default-policy learning generates action prediction error signals that decline as actions become habitual. Our results further suggest why both of these signals may need to coexist in the temporal difference errors in our model, and qualitatively reproduce key response patterns and simulations from studies previously used to support both views. Beyond this descriptive reconciliation, our model simulations also highlight the normative role of the tail of the striatum in cautious behaviours in the context of potential threats and stable learning in the face of outcome uncertainty.

neuroscience↗

Optimal composition of multiple value functions for dopamine-mediated efficient, safe and stable learning

AO_SCPLOWBSTRACTC_SCPLOWThe seminal reward prediction error account of dopamine has been highly successful, but faces several key challenges. Most notable are the difficulty of learning multiple rewards simultaneously, inefficient on-policy learning, and accounting for the heterogeneous striatal responses observed across and within striatal targets. Here we address these issues with a normative entropy-regularised reinforcement-learning framework. We propose that dopamine optimises not just cumulative rewards, but a reward value function augmented by a penalty for deviating from a default behavioural policy. In simulations, this off-policy formulation provides a principled solution to composing multiple reward values, avoids the interference and unintended unlearning seen in multi-objective on-policy methods when priorities change, and adapts more efficiently than standard alternatives in environments with non-stationary rewards. More broadly, the framework offers a unified account of dopamine heterogeneity between and within striatal targets, including a normative way to understand why aversive and action prediction errors may coexist in the tail of the striatum. Together, these results suggest that dopamine-mediated learning may be better captured by prediction errors in composable, entropy-regularised value functions than by a single broadcast prediction error, and offer testable predictions for future experiments.

neuroscience↗

Tonic pain revalues associative memories of phasic pain

Tonic pain is proposed to adapt protective behaviours during recovery from injury. A key untested prediction of this homeostatic model is that it appropriately reshapes internal representations of phasic pain. We investigated whether lateralised tonic pain modulates phasic pain-predictive cues on that side. Using a virtual-reality Pavlovian revaluation paradigm, we assessed physiological and neural conditioned responses with EEG in theta, alpha, and beta frequency bands. Pain-predictive cues elicited neural enhanced alpha and beta suppression and increased pupil diameter during conditioning acquisition. Critically, tonic pain revalued phasic conditioned responses during extinction, with reduced midfrontal theta synchronisation when the laterality of tonic pain was congruent with predicted phasic pain. Greater tonic pain unpleasantness also enhanced posterior beta suppression for congruent cues. These findings provide evidence for an internal representation of cue-pain associations that is topographically modulated by tonic pain, suggesting that tonic pain actively reconfigures pain predictions, enabling anticipatory protective behaviours.

neuroscience↗

Phasic and tonic pain serve distinct functions during adaptive behaviour

Pain drives self-protective behaviour, and evolutionary theories suggest it acts over different timescales to serve distinct functions. Whilst phasic pain provides a teaching signal to drive avoidance of new injury, tonic pain is argued to support recuperative behaviour, for instance by reducing motivational vigour. We test this hypothesis in an immersive virtual reality EEG foraging task where subjects harvested fruit in a forest: some fruit elicited brief phasic pain to the grasping hand, and this reduced choice probability. Simultaneously, tonic pressure pain to the contralateral upper arm was associated with reduced action velocities. This could be explained by a free-operant computational framework that formalises and quantifies the function of tonic and phasic pain in terms of motivational vigour and decision value, and model parameters correlated with physiological and neural responses. Overall, the results show how tonic and phasic pain subserve distinct objective motivational functions that support harm minimisation during ongoing adaptive behaviour.

neuroscience↗

Homeostasis After Injury: How Intertwined Inference and Control Underpin Post-Injury Pain and Behaviour

Injuries are an unfortunate but inevitable fact of life, leading to an evolutionary mandate for powerful homeostatic processes of recovery and recuperation. The physiological responses of the body and the immune system must be coordinated with behaviour to allow protected time for this to happen, and to prevent further damage to the affected bodily parts. Reacting appropriately requires an internal control system that represents the nature and state of the injury and specifies and withholds actions accordingly. We bring the formal uncertainties embodied in this system into the framework of a partially observable Markov decision process. We discuss nociceptive phenomena in light of this analysis, noting particularly the counter-intuitive behaviours associated with injury investigation, and the propensity for transitions from normative, tonic, to pathological, chronic pain states. Importantly, these simulation results provide a quantitative account and enable us to sketch a much needed roadmap for future theoretical and experimental studies on injury, tonic pain, and the transition to chronic pain. AO_SCPLOWUTHORC_SCPLOW SO_SCPLOWUMMARYC_SCPLOWSeveral arguments suggest that the brain has a dedicated representation of the state of an injury. This provides an internal control system to modulate our behaviour, influencing the pain, anxiety, and mood changes appropriate to the need for heightened protection and recuperation during healing. Here, we propose a computational architecture for how this system might be constructed. We model the injury as a problem where its true state is only partially observable, requiring the brain to combine inference with optimal control to make decisions. We show how this framework offers an explanation of two core paradoxical observations: it explains behaviours such as rubbing or probing an injured area so as to gain information and reduce uncertainty, and it accounts for the high propensity of an injury to transition into a pathological, chronic pain state via information restriction. Overall, this provides a quantitative framework for mapping the bodys healing processes to their underlying neural substrates. This has the potential to help researchers identify novel targets for treating and possibly preventing chronic pain.

neuroscience↗

Enhanced behavioural and neural sensitivity to punishments in chronic pain and fatigue

Chronic pain and fatigue in musculoskeletal disease contribute significantly to disability, and recent studies suggest an association with reduced motivation and excessive fear avoidance. In this behavioural neuroimaging study in chronic inflammatory arthritis participants and healthy controls, we aimed to identify the specific behavioral and neural changes associated pain and fatigue during reward and loss decision-making. Computational modeling of behaviour identified a parametric signature, characterized most notably by increased punishment sensitivity. This signature is distinct from patterns previously reported in psychiatric conditions and it aligns with predictions of mechanistic models of chronic pain such as the fear avoidance model. Neural activity associated with the punishment prediction error was enhanced in the right posterior insular cortex, putamen, pallidum, and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Functional network connectivity analysis showed that insula centrality correlated with subjective reports of fatigue and pain. Overall, the findings show that pain and fatigue in chronic pain relate to objective behavioural changes, and can be mapped to a specific pattern of activity in brain circuits of motivation and decision-making.

neuroscience↗

Balancing safety and efficiency in human decision making

The safety-efficiency dilemma describes the problem of maintaining safety during efficient exploration and is a special case of the exploration-exploitation dilemma in the face of potential dangers. Conventional exploration-exploitation solutions collapse punishment and reward into a single feedback signal, whereby early losses can be overcome by later gains. However, the brain has a separate system for Pavlovian fear learning, suggesting a possible computational advantage to maintaining a specific fear memory during exploratory decision-making. In a series of simulations, we show this promotes safe but efficient learning and is optimised by arbitrating Pavlovian avoidance of instrumental decision-making according to uncertainty. We provide a basic test of this model in a simple human approach-withdrawal experiment in virtual reality, and show that this flexible avoidance model captures choice and reaction times. These results show that the Pavlovian fear system has a more sophisticated role in decision-making than previously thought, by shaping flexible exploratory behaviour in a computationally precise manner.

neuroscience↗

Microbiota-dependent indole production is required for the development of collagen-induced arthritis

Altered tryptophan catabolism has been identified in inflammatory diseases like rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and spondyloarthritis (SpA), but the causal mechanisms linking tryptophan metabolites to disease are unknown. Using the collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) model we identify alterations in tryptophan metabolism, and specifically indole, that correlate with disease. We demonstrate that both bacteria and dietary tryptophan are required for disease, and indole supplementation is sufficient to induce disease in their absence. When mice with CIA on a low-tryptophan diet were supplemented with indole, we observed significant increases in serum IL-6, TNF, and IL-1{beta}; splenic ROR{gamma}t+CD4+ T cells and ex vivo collagen-stimulated IL-17 production; and a pattern of anti-collagen antibody isotype switching and glycosylation that corresponded with increased complement fixation. IL-23 neutralization reduced disease severity in indole-induced CIA. Finally, exposure of human colon lymphocytes to indole increased expression of genes involved in IL-17 signaling and plasma cell activation. Altogether, we propose a mechanism by which intestinal dysbiosis during inflammatory arthritis results in altered tryptophan catabolism, leading to indole stimulation of arthritis development. Blockade of indole generation may present a novel therapeutic pathway for RA and SpA.

immunology↗

Confidence of probabilistic predictions modulates the cortical response to pain

Pain typically evolves over time and the brain needs to learn this temporal evolution to predict how pain is likely to change in the future and orient behavior. This process is termed temporal statistical learning (TSL). Recently, it has been shown that TSL for pain sequences can be achieved using optimal Bayesian inference, which is encoded in somatosensory processing regions. Here, we investigate whether the confidence of these probabilistic predictions modulates the EEG response to noxious stimuli, using a TSL task. Confidence measures the uncertainty about the probabilistic prediction, irrespective of its actual outcome. Bayesian models dictate that the confidence about probabilistic predictions should be integrated with incoming inputs and weight learning, such that it modulates the early components of the EEG responses to noxious stimuli, and this should be captured by a negative correlation: when confidence is higher, the early neural responses are smaller as the brain relies more on expectations/predictions and less on sensory inputs (and vice versa). We show that participants were able to predict the sequence transition probabilities using Bayesian inference, with some forgetting. Then, we find that the confidence of these probabilistic predictions was negatively associated with the amplitude of the N2 and P2 components of the Vertex Potential: the more confident were participants about their predictions, the smaller was the Vertex Potential. These results confirm key predictions of a Bayesian learning model and clarify the functional significance of the early EEG responses to nociceptive stimuli, as being implicated in confidence-weighted statistical learning. SIGNIFICANCEThe functional significance of EEG responses to pain has long been debated because of their dramatic variability. This study indicates that such variability can be partly related to the confidence of probabilistic predictions emerging from sequences of pain inputs. The confidence of pain predictions is negatively associated with the cortical EEG responses to pain. This indicates that the brain relies less on sensory inputs when confidence is higher and shows us that confidence-weighted statistical learning modulates the cortical response to pain.

neuroscience↗

Endogenous modulation of pain relief: evidence for dopaminergic but not opioidergic involvement

Relief of ongoing pain is a potent motivator of behavior, directing actions to escape from or reduce potentially harmful stimuli. Whereas endogenous modulation of pain events is well characterized, relatively little is known about the modulation of pain relief and its corresponding neurochemical basis. Here we studied pain modulation during a probabilistic relief-seeking task (a wheel of fortune gambling task), in which people actively or passively received reduction of a tonic thermal pain stimulus. We found that relief perception was enhanced by active decisions and unpredictability, and greater in high novelty-seeking trait individuals, consistent with a model in which relief is tuned by its informational content. We then probed the roles of dopaminergic and opioidergic signaling, both of which are implicated in relief processing, by embedding the task in a double-blinded cross-over design with administration of the dopamine precursor levodopa and the opioid receptor antagonist naltrexone. We found that levodopa, but not naltrexone, enhanced each of these information-specific aspects of relief modulation. These results show that dopaminergic signaling has a key role in modulating the perception of pain relief to optimize motivation and behavior.

neuroscience↗

Learning the statistics of pain: computational and neural mechanisms

Pain invariably changes over time, and these temporal fluctuations are riddled with uncertainty about body safety. In theory, statistical regularities of pain through time contain useful information that can be learned, allowing the brain to generate expectations and inform behaviour. To investigate this, we exposed healthy participants to probabilistic sequences of low and high-intensity electrical stimuli to the left hand, containing sudden changes in stimulus frequencies. We demonstrate that humans can learn to extract these regularities, and explicitly predict the likelihood of forthcoming pain intensities in a manner consistent with optimal Bayesian models with dynamic update of beliefs. We studied brain activity using functional MRI whilst subjects performed the task, which allowed us to dissect the underlying neural correlates of these statistical inferences from their uncertainty and update. We found that the inferred frequency (posterior probability) of high intensity pain correlated with activity in bilateral sensorimotor cortex, secondary somatosensory cortex and right caudate. The uncertainty of statistical inferences of pain was encoded in the right superior parietal cortex. An intrinsic part of this hierarchical Bayesian model is the way that unexpected changes in frequency lead to shift beliefs and update the internal model. This is reflected by the KL divergence between consecutive posterior distributions and associated with brain responses in the premotor cortex, dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, and posterior parietal cortex. In conclusion, this study extends what is conventionally considered a sensory pain pathway dedicated to process pain intensity, to include the generation of Bayesian internal models of temporal statistics of pain intensity levels in sensorimotor regions, which are updated dynamically through the engagement of premotor, prefrontal and parietal regions.

neuroscience↗

Endogenous controllability of closed-loop brain-machine interfaces for pain.

The ultimate aim of closed-loop brain-machine systems for pain is to directly titrate the ongoing level of an intervention to pain-related neural activity. However pain is highly susceptible to endogenous modulation, raising the possibility that active or passive changes in neural activity provoked by the operation of the system could enhance or interfere with the signals upon which it is based. We studied healthy subjects receiving intermittent pain stimuli in a real-time fMRI-based closed-loop feedback-stimulation task. We showed that multi-voxel pattern decoding of pain intensity could be used to train a control algorithm to learn to deliver less painful stimuli (adaptive decoded neurofeedback). However, the system engaged two types of endogenous processes in the brain. First, despite the inherent incentive for subjects to enhance the neural decodability of pain, decodability was either reduced or unchanged in classic pain-processing regions, including insula, dorsolateral prefrontal, and somatosensory cortices. However, increased decodability was observed in a putative pain modulatory region - the pregenual anterior cingulate cortex (pgACC). Second, we found that pain perception itself was modulated by an endogenous computational uncertainty signal engaged as subjects learned the success rate of the system in reducing pain - an effect that also correlated with pgACC responses. The results illustrate how regionally and computationally specific co-adaptive brain-machine learning influences the efficacy of closed-loop systems for pain, and shows that pgACC acts as a key hub in the endogenous controllability of pain.

neuroscience↗

A prediction model of working memory across health and psychiatric disease using whole-brain functional connectivity

Individual differences in cognitive function have been shown to correlate with brain-wide functional connectivity, suggesting a common foundation relating connectivity to cognitive function across healthy populations. However, it remains unknown whether this relationship is preserved in cognitive deficits seen in a range of psychiatric disorders. Using machine learning methods, we built a prediction model of working memory function from whole-brain functional connectivity among a healthy population (N = 17, age 19-24 years). We applied this normative model to a series of independently collected resting state functional connectivity datasets (N = 968), involving multiple psychiatric diagnoses, sites, ages (18-65 years), and ethnicities. We found that predicted working memory ability was correlated with actually measured working memory performance in both schizophrenia patients (partial correlation,{rho} = 0.25, P = 0.033, N = 58) and a healthy population (partial correlation,{rho} = 0.11, P = 0.0072, N = 474). Moreover, the model predicted diagnosis-specific severity of working memory impairments in schizophrenia (N = 58, with 60 controls), major depressive disorder (N = 77, with 63 controls), obsessive-compulsive disorder (N = 46, with 50 controls), and autism spectrum disorder (N = 69, with 71 controls) with effect sizes g = -0.68, -0.29, -0.19, and 0.09, respectively. According to the model, each diagnosiss working memory impairment resulted from the accumulation of distinct functional connectivity differences that characterizes each diagnosis, including both diagnosis-specific and diagnosis-invariant functional connectivity differences. Severe working memory impairment in schizophrenia was related not only with fronto-parietal, but also widespread network changes. Autism spectrum disorder showed greater negative connectivity that related to improved working memory function, suggesting that some non-normative functional connections can be behaviorally advantageous. Our results suggest that the relationship between brain connectivity and working memory function in healthy populations can be generalized across multiple psychiatric diagnoses. This approach may shed new light on behavioral variances in psychiatric disease and suggests that whole-brain functional connectivity can provide an individual quantitative behavioral profile in a range of psychiatric disorders.

neuroscience↗

Anterior cingulate cortex connectivity is associated with suppression of behavior in a rat model of chronic pain

A cardinal feature of persistent pain that follows injury is a general suppression of behavior, in which motivation is inhibited in a way that promotes energy conservation and recuperation. Across species, the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) is associated with the motivational aspects of phasic pain, but whether it mediates motivational functions in persistent pain is less clear. Using burrowing behavior as an marker of non-specific motivated behavior in rodents, we studied the suppression of burrowing following painful CFA or control injection into the right knee-joint of 37 rats (18 with pain), and examined associated neural connectivity with ultra-high-field resting state functional MRI. We found that connectivity between ACC and the subcortex correlated with the reduction in burrowing behavior observed following the pain manipulation. In a full replication study we confirmed these findings in a group of 44 rats (23 with pain). Across both datasets, reduced burrowing was assosciated with increased connectivity between ACC and subcortical structures including hypothalamic/preoptic nuclei and the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis. Together, the findings implicate ACC connectivity as a robust correlate of the motivational aspect of persistent pain in rodents.

neuroscience↗

Classification and characterisation of brain network changes in chronic back pain: a multicenter study.

Chronic pain is a common and often disabling condition, and is thought to involve a combination of peripheral and central neurobiological factors. However, the extent and nature of changes in the brain is poorly understood. Here, we investigated brain network architecture using resting state fMRI data collected from chronic back pain patients in UK and Japan (41 patients, 56 controls). Using a machine learning approach (support vector machine), we found that brain network patterns reliably classified chronic pain patients in a third, independent open data set with an accuracy of 63%, whilst 68% was attained in cross validation of all data. We then developed a deep learning classifier using a conditional variational autoencoder, which also yield yielded 63% generalisation and 68% cross-validation accuracy. Given the existence of reliable network changes, we next studied the graph topology of the network, and found consistent evidence of hub disruption based on clustering and betweenness centrality of brain nodes in pain patients. To examine this in more detail, we developed a multislice modularity algorithm to identify a consensus pattern of modular reorganisation of brain nodes across the entire data set. This revealed evidence of significant changes in the modular identity of several brain regions, most notably including broad regions of bilateral sensorimotor cortex, subregions of which also contributed to classifier performance. These results provide evidence of consistent and characteristic brain network changes in chronic pain, and highlight extensive reorganisaton of the network architecture of sensorimotor cortex.

neuroscience↗

The Control of Tonic Pain by Active Relief Learning

Tonic pain after injury characterises a behavioural state that prioritises recovery. Although generally suppressing cognition and attention, tonic pain needs to allow effective relief learning so that the cause of the pain can be reduced if possible. Here, we describe a central learning circuit that supports learning of relief and concurrently suppresses the level of ongoing pain. We used computational modelling of behavioural, physiological and neuroimaging data in two experiments in which subjects learned to terminate tonic pain in static and dynamic escape-learning paradigms. In both studies, we show that active relief-seeking involves a reinforcement learning process manifest by error signals observed in the dorsal putamen. Critically, this system also uses an uncertainty ( associability) signal detected in pregenual anterior cingulate cortex that both controls the relief learning rate, and endogenously and parametrically modulates the level of tonic pain. The results define a self-organising learning circuit that allows reduction of ongoing pain when learning about potential relief.

neuroscience↗